9725 Takin' a break
by Neuferland

Comment by Malokata:
Nice picture, though the lighting effect looks odd on the corners.

9725 Takin' a break
by Neuferland

Comment by Brad:
Nice tone & composition.
Shame about the vignetting on the upper corners.

9725 Takin' a break
by Neuferland

Comment by omnibus:
I think this would look better in color - the old timey feel doesn't really suit the modern diesel engine, and color would show off the bright yellow and red UP paint scheme.

9725 Takin' a break
by Neuferland

Comment by L1:
Beautiful treatment...very nostalgic feel. :o)

Waiting For His Turn
by Neuferland

Comment by menardmam:
I give 5 to meet the challenge
+2 if the idea is great, orininal, and cautch my attention
+2 if it add the wow factore
10 for the exeptional one...

I give your picture 5 (meat the challenge, nothing more)

Hope it help !

Waiting For His Turn
by Neuferland

Comment by soccerdad:
I thought the border distracted, and I think cghubbel was right about the POV. Without the title, I thought he was waiting for the game to start, so I wrong, but it was still waiting. The other thing I thought was just a bit too much sky/trees, as they distracted a bit from the setting/subject combination.

All that said though, just because I didn't think it was great for the competition, I did think it was a nice picture.

Waiting For His Turn
by Neuferland

Comment by MWitt:
Seems a little underexposed. The border detracts instead of helping, because it makes the photo even darker. A light border might have helped that aspect. I didn't think it fit the challenge. I think if you had some other players in the photo that he was supposed to be waiting on, it would have done better. I hope that helps.

Waiting For His Turn
by Neuferland

Comment by redmondson01:
I gave you a 6. Sorry, It does not POP like some others in the challenge. Seems a little dark to me, and maybe could use better cropping? The fence on the right is distracting. IMHO I am new to this...

Waiting For His Turn
by Neuferland

Comment by scalvert:
I thought it was a good shot and gave it a 7. The composition was very good, but the light is a little flat, and it doesn't express waiting as well as some other shots did. Without reading the title, the wait aspect is kind of obscure.

9725 Takin' a break
by Neuferland

Comment by thunderbug:
I like the feel this one gives. Great job