Prometheus
by vawendy

Comment by andrewt:
Congrats on the Top 10 , excellent finish.

Retro's
by vawendy

Comment by Jutilda:
I love this. A fun moment.

Has anyone seen my car keys!?
by vawendy

Comment by rlewis:
appears out of focus

Prometheus
by vawendy

Comment by GiorgioBaruffi:
too little this fire, but nice shot...

Has anyone seen my car keys!?
by vawendy

Comment by FourPointX:
cute picture but a little bit of a shoehorn. 6

End of Summer
by vawendy

Comment by vlado:
Commenting as part of my Team Suck duties...

Beautiful sunset photo Wendy. I particularly love the clouds and the colours. If I was to pick on this at all, it would be the composition (I guess), in that the shoreline, the horizon and the boat/surfski/kayak/surfboard/? are all at different angles, and the boat/surfski/kayak/surfboard/? breaks the horizon line... I think the later of the two is the bigger issue really, because I think that the image could have worked with a variety of angles if only the horizon wasn't intersected as it is. Also, the plant in the water on the right is a minor distraction, though, I can see that losing that would have lost you the rule of thirds composition (which I like)... tough call. One last thing... horizon is a bit to close to centred... perhaps taking the photo from closer to the ground might have got the horizon lower and separated it from the boat/surfski/kayak/surfboard/?... but I wasn't there and I don't know what you could and couldn't have done here. :)

I hope this is useful feedback and doesn't come across too critical. I really do like this image, but think there was so much potential in it, but for a few minor things.

Has anyone seen my car keys!?
by vawendy

Comment by tinkie2010:
Cat could have been sharper...

Has anyone seen my car keys!?
by vawendy

Comment by mark082:
A tough sell in this challenge. :-) Overall, I think the photo lacks the sharpness I would have liked. I don't know if the shutter speed was slightly too long or if the focus point wasn't quite on his eye, but it just doesn't quite have it. 5

Has anyone seen my car keys!?
by vawendy

Comment by HarveyG:
I see what you have tried here but the DOF OOF makes me score it low, sorry!

End of Summer
by vawendy

Comment by Yo_Spiff:
Did well with this. 5.8 in a freestudy is darn good in my book. I skipped the vote on it of course.