Chameleon in Yellow
by hlswilson

Comment:
Composition: 7, I don't really like the rectangular composition here.
Technical: 10, I can't find anything wrong with this technically.. It's sharp, clean, and wonderfully lit.
Appeal: 8, Definitely very artsy, with a nice appeal.
Challenge: 4, I had to dock you on this, as this really is more orangey-red, with the only yellow feel being highlights on the face, and slight ones at that.
Overall Calculated Average Score: 7, Were it more "Yellow", a much higher score.

chillin
by arngrimur

Comment:
Composition: 8, A quirky composition, but it works for me.
Technical: 8, A little bit of noise in the darker areas.
Appeal: 6, It's funny, but there's not much of an appeal factor other than that, for me.
Challenge: 5, This would definitely fit a *blue* challenge better, as that color seems to be the impact. The yellow duck, for me, is just an after-thought.
Overall Calculated Average Score: 7, It's a nice photograph, but needed to be stronger on the challenge in my opinion.

On the Beach
by Bud

Comment:
Composition: 9, A pretty strong composition. The upper "horizon" line in the background would have been nice to see eliminated
Technical: 7, Slightly noisy and over-exposed in areas
Appeal: 10, This has a great appeal for me. Nostalgic, classic, and fun
Challenge: 7, It has yellow in it, but I'm not sure if it's as strong as it could be if you'd tried to keep the sand a little more colorful.
Overall Calculated Average Score: 8

Tiny Heart Beats
by lmhr

Comment:
Absolutely gorgeous and timeless.. A treasure.

Give me a 10.... or the Camera gets it!
by Artyste

Comment:
A big thank you to everyone who commented. Commenters on this image gave me an average of 7.556... non commenters a 5.155.

That's probably the largest difference in score between commenters and non-commenters I've ever had.

I don't understand why this did so poorly at all... Totally, absolutely, completely blows my mind. Yah, the figure in the background is a little motion-blurred in areas, but not where it counts. (hard to time the swinging of a camera strap when you have all of 10 seconds to get into the shot and pose it). I just don't get it.

I didn't expect 7s.. or even mid 6s.. but a 5.1?! *shakes head*

I'll never understand what makes the masses happy. I'm too deeply *me*.
This.. is why I fail.

Merry X-mas Viagra
by Prime_Time

Comment:
This got a 9 from me as well. Extremely funny shot, and *well* shot.

No accounting for the idiocy of DPC voters though.

going-swimming.jpg
by robdoc

Comment:

Originally posted by Beagleboy: A lot of artifacts around the child. I've never had this problem. Do you know what caused this?

It looks like it's been resized up from a smaller image.

Leda's tragic obsession.
by pcody

Comment:
How risque. Bear/Duck love is so tragic.

Redneck Windchime
by Brenb

Comment:
lol.. prettty funny.

Cheap Lens
by postoakinversion

Comment:
hehehe.. this is a great idea. Nice hair btw.