Steamboat Willie
by BAMartin

Comment:
very nice composition... my only critique would be the darkness on the detail... I can definitely tell that these are old but I think a little highlighting on the details would be nice as well... good work :) = 9 - jmsetzler

I'm a little rusty
by aripps

Comment:
this is definitely a nice subject for the 'old' challenge... the background, however, does not contribute much to that concept. Maybe it woud have been possible to move to a better area, maybe not :) - jmsetzler

The Foundation of Life
by Ronin

Comment:
i love the texture and desigh here.. the black and white compliments the contrast here very well... great shot :) - jmsetzler

Lesney Toy Truck
by LanSnake

Comment:
excellent work with the lighting and background preparation for this shot... a little extra depth of field to keep the entire truck in focus would have worked a little better for me :) good shot ... - jmsetzler

This Old House
by jerry

Comment:
this is a neat view, but I think the tree is blocking too much of your subject in this photo. I wonder if there would have been a better angle to photograph this house? - jmsetzler

A hand that's been through a lifetime
by fas-ligand

Comment:
I think this is an excellent subject for this challenge... My only critique is that that background is a little busy for my taste... good shot :) - jmsetzler

Let's Play in the Loft
by karmat

Comment:
this is a neat image, but I would love to see the ground at the door entrance on the bottom of the barn... there is no 'entrance' in this photo... the colors are a little flat, but that works ok with the 'old' theme of this challenge... - jmsetzler

This Machine...
by Patella

Comment:
This is definitely a nice photograph of an old camera... I think you could have achieved the depth of field you wanted by backing up a little bit and working with the resolution of your camera to crop a section from a larger photo. Some cameras don't work as well at close range as others do... -jmsetzler

Still Frisky
by JEFFCOWLES

Comment:
This is an excellent composition and I love the shadow play in this photo. My only trouble is that I don't think I understand what I'm looking at and i'm not receiving the 'old' message. I assume the object that is holding the brandy snifter is old possibly... I may need some help with this one after the challenge :) - jmsetzler

Fond Memories
by Sonifo

Comment:
interesting house :) I like the composition with the exception of the tree on the right... I have this personal issue with trees sometimes... I believe that they should either be in or out of the frame. This one is dissected by the right edge of the frame. I also think that the branckes are covering up some nice detail of your subject... - jmsetzler