Gathering Storm
by nicowens

Comment:
This is an interesting concept for 'new'... The horizon is nice and level... I'm not sure that I really like the sharp contrast between the white and dark in the sky against the water in this one... seems a little flat :) - jmsetzler

BRAND new trainer
by tunnard

Comment:
Good shot :) This is the beginning of a nice product shot for Reebok :) I like the side lighting on this photo. I think this photo would benefit somewhat from a dark solid background possibly. Even though the background is blurred nicely in this image, it is offering some contrasting colors that create a minor distraction from your subject... good work :) - jmsetzler

Waiting for a Sunny Day
by alanfreed

Comment:
I love photos like this one where the fine details stand out so sharply. This is an excellent image and I can't see much room for improvement at all... good work :) - 9 - jmsetzler

Old Friends
by cameo

Comment:
good composition on this photo... the light on the doll's head is just a bit weak... good job with the catch light in the doll's eyes :) - jmsetzler

Jean Newhart, Antiques
by sjgleah

Comment:
very nice composition... i *LIKE* the flat colors here and think it works veyr well.. it may even work well in black and white... good shot :) - jmsetzler

pre-digital
by queen 91

Comment:
I think your cnoice of subject is good for this challenge... I think you possibly could have uncovered a different perspective on this photo to give it some more punch. The lighting isn't quite even across the frame from left to right.. it gets darker as we move from one side to the other... - jmsetzler

Grandpa Ben's Books
by GeneralE

Comment:
This is a nice choice of subjects for this challenge... I believe this image needs a little more sharpness overall... Possibly a lower camera angle as well... :) - jmsetzler

Old Bones
by warglory

Comment:
very nice :) I think the lighting is just about perfect on this shot... the dark background works well also :) - jmsetzler

Stopped In It's Tracks
by timj351

Comment:
excellent photo... question... is there a wooded area on the left side of this tractor? If so, it may have been better to photograph it from the other side to provide a better background... This photo works really well as is though.. i love the dandilions in front of the tractor :) = 8 - jmsetzler

Waterfront Home. Needs Work
by BigSmiles

Comment:
nice view :) I like the overhead perspectiveo n this shot... This looks like a place I would have played as a child... good shot :) - jmsetzler