Seedless
by titotapado

Comment:
You have effectively captured the challenge by photographing this watermelon... In my opinion, the subject lacks punch or pizazz. When I look at this photo, I say to myself, "Yep... that's a watermelon." I am looking for an eye-catching view... something that intrigues me... some part of the image that I can get lost in... When making photos for the challenges, keep in mind that visual impact plays an important role :) - jmsetzler

Gai Lan Stalks
by Jak

Comment:
This is an interesting image... One of my personal hang ups is that I don't care for photos that lack 'dimension'. I love a full three dimensional effect moreso that a flat appearance. - jmsetzler

Heavenly Apples
by manda4343

Comment:
Interesting effect... The brown edge around the red apple looks a little strange to me. That may be a remnant of the post processing maybe? good shot :) - jmsetzler

Drought year apple.
by jimsapp

Comment:
You did an excellent job of capturing your subject in this photo.. the clarity and depth of field are very nice :) Personally, I would have composed this apple a little more off center (rule of thirds composition) to provide some more visual impact... good shot :) - jmsetzler

Hot Potato
by Konador

Comment:
great shot... I can smell this potato cooking... = 9 - jmsetzler

Blushing Bowl
by Agamemnon

Comment:
nicely composed... I like the color as well.. reds and black work nicely together :) the lighting seems a bit awkward in this image... the light spot in the upper right corner is not obtrusive, but only mildly distracting.... - jmsetzler

Watermelon Stars
by #1 Bronco Fan

Comment:
I really like the use of the reflections in this image... excellent composition as well.. good work :) - jmsetzler

Serrano Sublime
by lmhr

Comment:
I like mine hot :) I went with a similar theme this week... good shot :) - jmsetzler

Lunchtime
by CreativeFlyPhoto

Comment:
I should have saved this one for after dinner :) I love the color and composition in this photo... great work.. it is making me hungry :) = 9 - jmsetzler

Planet of the fruits
by snaeland

Comment:
this is a nice attempt... I htink the post processing may have washed out some of the detail.... since this is a closeup and some of the detail is visible, i believe it needs to be sharper overall... good idea :) - jmsetzler