"my essentials" by melodee
by k4ffy

Comment:
nearly the same arrangements - thank you for sticking close to the original. only the idea I mean. Execution is MUCH better. DOF is good. The only point I could see an improvement in: lighting. actually it's more reflections of your lighting that needs to support the idea of metal. Having a white reflection on the metal sufaces creates the metal/silver appearance.

Kitty Nose With Appel <sic> 2.1409
by lynnesite

Comment:
I apreciate that you are close to the original. Very good reshooting. Good choice of focus.

Floweryness (Seven Deadly Sins II Challenge)
by banmorn

Comment:
I appreciate that you kept close to the original. The execution of your picture is excellent. composition, color tones and DOF are perfect,

Kitty Nose with Appel
by cheekymunky

Comment:
well thought through. the composition and color matching of apple and eyes.

Drain, Drain Go Away by ScubaSteve13 (Image ID: 501654)
by Quasimojo

Comment:
yes, a very successful reshoot. you stayed really close to the original. I appreciate this very much. lighting is great, focus is spot on. well done

six redone
by nlghttrain

Comment:
well done, a much more pleasing image and interpretation. Good choice of DOF.

Light As A Feather
by shamer

Comment:
Well, how can I describe the difference to the original: light years apart?
great concept, great execution, 10

Pinecone Sunlight - Foreground Bokeh
by sherpet

Comment:
bravo, a picture in the true sense of the challenge. May be a little bit oversaturated (But that could be my monitor). 9

See: "the engineering marvels of general electric [aka where's the butter]"
by colorcarnival

Comment:
LOL, guess you found the butter in the fridge with the lights turned off. Got to love your humor. I have to assume jonathans took the picture from inside with the door closed :), 8

Bloom in the rain ("The Letter B" challenge)
by androgeus

Comment:
It's not the same flower. But besides that, lighting is controlled very well. no motion blur on the water drops. good vibrant colors, focus exposed great detail. 7