Docklands-Vic-Harbour-019-v.jpg
by jomari

Comment:
I think this is the best of the three although the only change I can see is the cloning out of a few small hairlines around the two pylons.
Nice editing job Marion.

At the Beach
by Hipychik

Comment:
Wow! What a transformation. Crop is terrific. Your PP has brought out the detail in the children and the DOF nicely.

unravelled
by Retroesque

Comment:
I think that this would be a whole heap better if you had different brands and colours of toilet paper Lisa. What better place to have a choice. Looks like wherever this is they really value their TP - ie. padlock and all.

Week 3: Canon G2 CRW3290 r720 Edited.jpg
by Neil

Comment:
I think you've done a pretty good job with this Neil. The detail in the post and rails , the snow and the trees mid ground are much better than the original IMHO. I think I'd prefer the orange in the sky toned down a touch or perhaps bring in a small amount of magenta to soften it a bit. Maybe a selected ninja to reduce the noise in the snow just behind the fence. And yes! What is the cloud type formation in the centre left of the image. I also agree with roz with regard to the crop - I like the original in this regard with the fence turning back on itself.

High Rise
by cgino

Comment:
Nice crop Colleen. Also glad you skewed the building so that it was vertical. One of my pet hates. The gold highlights in the pond add another dimension to the water and the rocks below and in this case I like the way you have blown out the sky in the background. It makes the whole scene very architectural and sketchy.

Number 4 - Descending
by Kelli

Comment:
This is very impressionistic Kelli. I like the treatment you've done to this. The painter effect has really brought out the underlying colours in the leaves.

Highland Lighthouse (APAW-3bw)
by PGerst

Comment:
I like the B&W version better than the colour. I really brings out the stark white of the lighthouse tower which in turn leads the eye to the light chamber.

Reflecting on The Flight From Pompeii.
by jomari

Comment:
great processing marion. you've really given some depth to this image. excellent framing.

Wood Turner
by DistantColours

Comment:
Hey Darren...this was my pick for the blue.....don't feel too bad (and I know that's very easy to say...I'd be really pissed off)....but whether it's been DQ'd or not, you've still got the knowledge that during voting it was the 5th most popular image out of 530 entrants!

Punk
by yakatme

Comment:
This was one of my top 3. Simple but exquisitely done. Congrats on your top 7% finish.