The Nylon Curtain
by gsal

Comment:
First Impression: Too much photoshop


Total Averaged Rating :6

Death of a Saguaro
by FotoHunter

Comment:
First Impression: tells a story
Presentation:good
What I Like:
What I donĂ¢€™t Like:
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: good
Background : ok
Subject Placement: good
Cropping: good
Focus: soft
Exposure:good
Editing:good

Total Averaged Rating :8

Wassup?
by TallisMan

Comment:
First Impression: A lovely bird portrait
Presentation:good
What I Like: the birds attitude
What I donĂ¢€™t Like:the slight over exposure
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: good
Background :v good depth of field
Subject Placement: good
Cropping: good
Focus: good
Exposure: slight over exposure
Editing:good

Total Averaged Rating :7

In Van Gogh's Garden
by Neil

Comment:
First Impression:i would hang it on my wall
Presentation:very good
What I Like:everything
What I donĂ¢€™t Like:
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: excellent
Background :excellent
Subject Placement:excellent
Cropping:excellent
Focus: excellent
Exposure:perfect
Editing:ok

Total Averaged Rating :9

Intensity
by gg3rd

Comment:
First Impression: nice portrait
Presentation:good
What I Like: the duotone
What I donĂ¢€™t Like: the deadness in the eyes they have no detail in them
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: good
Background :good
Subject Placement:good
Cropping:good
Focus: soft but that is ok for this
Exposure:ok
Editing:ok

Total Averaged Rating :6

To The Market
by phatphoto

Comment:
First Impression:a love bit of local colour
Presentation:good
What I Like:The colours and her expression
What I donĂ¢€™t Like: the title it doesn't fit the image if she is going to market where is her basket
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: good
Background :good
Subject Placement: good
Cropping:good
Focus: v good
Exposure: v good
Editing:good

Total Averaged Rating :9

The Dancing Building
by elemess

Comment:
First Impression:interesting building
Presentation:good
What I Like: the sky
What I donĂ¢€™t Like:it looks like a drawing
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: good
Background :good
Subject Placement:v good
Cropping:good
Focus: good
Exposure:good
Editing:over edited for my taste

Total Averaged Rating :6

Autumn
by jdannels

Comment:
First Impression:pretty spot
Presentation:good
What I Like:the area
What I donĂ¢€™t Like:the washed out colour
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: Could have been improved by cutting out some of the sand on thright and some of the foreground
Background :ok
Subject Placement:You should have made more use of the fisherman
Cropping:ok
Focus: i think it was probably a bit soft and has now been over sharpened
Exposure:overexposure has washed out the colour
Editing:oversharpened

Total Averaged Rating :6

Grooming Partners
by Matthew

Comment:
First Impression: Cute I seem to have seen these two before
Presentation:Good
What I Like: the eye contact with the bottom monkey
What I donĂ¢€™t Like: looks like too much flash
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: good
Background :v good
Subject Placement:v good
Cropping:good
Focus: good
Exposure: some blown highlights
Editing: seems too have a tad too much USM

Total Averaged Rating :7

Look Away
by banmorn

Comment:
First Impression: A lovely black and white art photograph
Presentation: good
What I Like: the toning
What I donĂ¢€™t Like:nothing
IMO, Does it meet the Challenge : yes

Composition: a slightly too big a gap between the bottom flower and the top two
Background : compliments the subject
Subject Placement: good
Cropping:good
Focus: good
Exposure:slightly overexposed
Editing:good

Total Averaged Rating : 8