The Whole Gang (Mine's the Cat)
by Cantique

Comment:
the photo would look better if it was straight, but your cat is superb!!!!!

State Pride
by Resusit8u

Comment:
Wow.... what an impressive display!

Happy Dude
by TommyMoe21

Comment:
There is something missing...... hmmm...... wonder what it could be? Oh I get it - where is the candle? This thing is supposed to shine and glow!!! I do like the rest of the lighting, though.

Painting with a flashlight
by TLL061

Comment:
The pumpkin - nicely carved. The background - (nearly) nice and black. The moodlighting - just right to illuminate the pumpkin to let us see detail. The glow - where on earth is the candle? How can you NOT have a light in that pumpkin? Aaaaaarrrgggghhhhhhh!!!

Oh, Nooooooo! (the Scream)
by lynnesite

Comment:
I've come back to this photo 3 times now, and I still can't work out why they hands are on the wrong sides. Pity, because it is a rather original design.

Trick or Treat
by rwouthuis

Comment:
I like your effort with the setup, it really sets the mood. Nice atmosphere, nice photo. 8

Pumpkin Cannibalis
by Azrifel

Comment:
The photo is.... well........ ok (the glare is a problem), but the pumpkin is terrific! 7

DSC_1416.jpg
by nomad469

Comment:
Oh wow...... I just saw the orginal of this photo (posted in a forum thread).... you did a wonderful job in PS.
I realized that this must have been.... ummm....... say: enhanced, but the difference is phenomenal. The original is very bland, but this version is so eyecatching. Guess I'm a sucker for drama and color.
Very nice!

THE EXECUTIONERS' GHOST
by POLO

Comment:
Apart from the blown highlights and the yellow cast, I don't see the connection to the challenge, sorry :-(

Shunned
by EddyG

Comment:
Superb!!!!!! Brilliant grasp of the challenge concept. You truly got some emotion across here, well done!