He Tried To Put A Lid On It
by Tap10

Comment:
although i'm thankful for the change from paper to look at--i spent way too much time trying to understand the title (that won't affect your score from me). this is an otherwise generally interesting picture. It seems a bit soft, and the numbers on the paper lack resolution with a slight tilt to the right. The colors are a bit flat as well. I do like the creativity.

Tied
by diannarae

Comment:
sorry, i fail to understand how this meets the challenge.

Misty (take 2)
by Tim

Comment:
I was just browsing and I love this shot! It's beautiful. I love the fog--gives a nice mood. My only critique would be that the tree in the foreground on the left side is pretty dark/in silhouette. I'm not sure it detracts a whole lot--but otherwise the rest of the photo is perfect.

Tinted glow
by facesastheycome

Comment:
hmm...this is an interesting idea--but I just don't see much of a "subject" If it's the window directly in the center then I think the two windows on either side should be cropped out--as well as the black line across the bottom. It's also not in good focus and the detail is lacking.

Lost and Found
by Zoomdak

Comment:
what and where is that? On technical merits alone this photo does well--it's interesting to look at and has a nice texture. I'm guessing this is done with perspective to make the glass ball look larger--but it's very well done. Nice colors of the sky reflected in the sand as well.

Can't Read Without It...
by cardmaverick

Comment:
This is such a cool idea. I love it. I wish the lettering could have come out right side up (I realize it's a function of the optics at work). Very cool idea.

Mirror Image
by HikerDude

Comment:
wonderfully beautiful picture. great reflection in the water. Looks great.

Riding The Storm Out
by 4forfun

Comment:
I'm sure you've already been told this, but it's hard to rate a picture when it's so small. It looks like it might be good, but would be nice to resize it a bit larger.

Waterfalls
by jonr

Comment:
wow, this is a truly amazing shot. I'm sure this would look great edited too, but even without editing I'd be so proud of this shot. I love the lines of the falls and the soft blue of the water.

Mediocre Break
by freakin_hilarious

Comment:
nice finish. after you told me i gave you a good review i wondered which one was yours. I still think this is the best of the pool shots. I hope to do as well in my upcoming challenge.