Abstracts, Spring Catalogue - Pg. 69
by tnun

Comment:
Another non-product product shot. I just don't get why your collective didn't choose a side challenge for these abstracts. It is an excellent shot, but very off-topic - I cannot make the connection that the image itself is the product. Also, since this was broadly and collectively coordinated, It's hard to vote this as an individual submission.

Chardon'A The World's Finest Maple Syrup
by thatsanicepicture

Comment:
Ohh, so close to being a outstanding shot. The white balance is off and that seam in the wall paper kills the image.

'Forbidden Fruit' Seed Catalog
by pointandshoot

Comment:
Don't get the title as it pertains to the image and it doesn't show of the Product.

Page Six: I am not a number. I am a free man.
by skewsme

Comment:
The Product being the flower? If that is the case, then this misses the mark as a Product Shot. Nice image though.

Abstracts, Spring Catalog — Pg. 11
by PenelopeK

Comment:
Again. Team Abstract is certainly redefining DNMC. Another excellent shot that would've doen great in another challenge - possibly Fine Art or Abstract, but to submit an image as the product itself just doesn't work for me. Again great shot, poor choice for this challenge. As I have said to a few of your other teammates, It's very difficult to vote this as a individual shot when it is clear that this was collectively done.

Abstracts : Spring Catalog — Pg. 37
by Bear_Music

Comment:
I feel as though I have voted on this already. I hesitate to click to the next image for fear of getting another abstract in a Product Shot challenge. Trepidity sets in an I move on...

Electric Sunglasses
by dborto

Comment:
The electric symbol screams that it wants to be in color. Placement in the frame seems a bit off.

Abstracts, Spring Catalogue — Pg. 87
by rooum

Comment:
Love the image, but again, the image as the product doesn't fit the challenge and, as I have commented to the others, It's hard to vote the image a single submission knowning that these were a collective effort by a group.

Abstracts, Spring Catalogue — Pg. 101
by colorcarnival

Comment:
I just don't get why a collective would try to do a series of abstracts for a Product Shot challenge with the image itself as the product. Propose an Abstracts challenge.

Coke add life
by whiterook

Comment:
Lots of issues with this image - white balance, tilted frame, clipped subject, flat lighting...