Treasures of the past
by sallyjo1

Comment:
It looks like the picture quality suffered when it was uploaded - it's very pixelated, even in the corners. This could easily have been cropped to a portrait orientation, and that might have saved a bit on the file size. If I can't Save for Web at 80% minimum, I won't upload it.

Earth Mover
by holdingtime

Comment:
The perspective here is just odd. The weighting is disconcerting. The wheels should be anchored to the bottom of the picture. Remember that the bottom of a picture is almost always perceived to be the ground, the front, closer, etc. Anything that looms large in the top of the frame looks like it's flying and that just doesn't work in this photo's favor. I'd also like to see more of the object you're shooting and less of its rock stage.

Iron History
by Sylva7

Comment:
Great texture in this photo, nice clarity - the only thing that distracts is the white space in the upper left corner. It feels like you cut the corner off. I'd like to see the wall and stairs fill the entire frame.

Wise Canine
by catholicskin

Comment:
Is the dog old?

Tropical Detritus
by fatLouie

Comment:
I would like to get closer in to the building - it looks a lot more interesting than the sky and tree top. I would be shooting all over this building, not so far back from it.

Knitting Needles From Five Generations Ago!
by 777STAN

Comment:
I'm not sure what the deal is with the radioactive mini needle thingies..? The post-shoot work done on that area looks very weird.

Heritage Cameo - Camée
by dube140463

Comment:
The cameo itself is out of focus - looks like the blanket it's resting on is a lot sharper in the foreground.

Grandad's Old Bike
by MacT

Comment:
Very overexposed. Increase your shutter speed by a click or two.

Old Sport
by Judi

Comment:
The cowboy is young, the horse is young, the calf is young... I definitely would not make the connection to anything about this photo being "old" without the title to tell me so, which makes its inclusion in this challenge a bit of a stretch. My score would be several points higher if it nailed the challenge.

I aint Old, just new hair cut
by DigiFotoBuddy

Comment:
If it isn't old, then how does it fit the challenge? Stricly about the photo, the bird's shoulder feathers are sharper than his face, where the focus should be.