Bubble Tea
by h2

Comment:
A very good emulation. 8

Tribute to Squeak (Pet Portrait III)
by timfythetoo

Comment:
Should be an emotional favorite for anyone who's read the forums in the past week. Nicely done! 8

Tribute to jagar's entry in the "Photo Tutorial" challenge
by AllenP

Comment:
A very good emulation of jagar's image. Outsatnding b/w. Maybe slightly too grainy for me, but outstanding overall. 8

Big Red (homage to "RED" by ScooterMcNutty)
by smardaz

Comment:
Great job. This made me laugh and enjoy. I suspect this will be a top ten image. 9

by Bear_Music

Comment:
I do like this a lot. sekarmalathy did more of a close-up. But, your capture is effective in a different way. I think it's a good emulation and creative in its own sense. (a polarizing filter would have removed the glare off of some of the wet leaves). 9

At Your Service for Decades Redux - A tribute to Gyaban
by Samantha_T

Comment:
Exceptionally well done! I suspect this will be a ribbon contender. 10

Pears and Pitcher (Still-Life with Fruit)
by grahamgator

Comment:
This is one of my top picks in this challenge. A good emulation of the original. Your image is a very fine SL in its own right. Well done! 10

Contemplating the Infinite
by Yo_Spiff

Comment:
This is my favorite in this challenge. I love the luminous glow on the water and the sky detail and color gradient is magnificent. You've emulated DrAchoo's image by improving upon it. I much prefer your image proportions. It does rhyme with the original, but is not an attempt to copy. Great job! 10

Trying The Paleo Diet
by 1m1A

Comment:
It's a good action shot. Well captured. Our community has leash laws for cats. Domestic cats kill many desirable songbirds, because it's their nature, not because they're hungry.

Rich Harvest
by albrix

Comment:
I gave you a 7 on this image. I love the natural look. Colors seem natural and pleasant to me. The blurred background is good, but the oof apples hanging around distract slightly. I might have darkened the outside portions a bit. Square formats are not eye-pleasing. Has to be the right subject to go for centered and symmetrical. Your subject is not symmetrical. Overall, this is an okay photo. Can't explain the 2s. Not very nice voters these days.