Robot
by GinaRothfels

Comment:
a wonderful image. i gave it an 8. i knew it would be sorely unappreciated. i ilke not only the image, and the construction of it, but also the fact that you had the guts to submit an image so wonderfully, deceptively, simple to an expert editing challenge. well done indeed!

'They could spy upon you night and day, but if you kept your head you could still outwit them.'
by Bruce_the_Robert

Comment:
excellent image, rob. i gave it an 8. it fitted the theme very well indeed - as thankfully orwell's dystopia is still (somewhat, although i've been hearing rather worrying things from the uk) sci-fi. i like the fact that you used the expert editing subtly, and made it wrk for you. great stuff!

Evolution of the Species
by DrAchoo

Comment:
excellent doc. one of the very few 10s i've ever given out.

Morning Dew
by Muppet

Comment:
i think the criticisms that have come before are all valid (size, slant) so i'll go with what i like. the subtlety is good, but i do believe a close up of only the bar, mesh and droplets would make a much better and more dramatic shot.

well done for noticing this, seeing is half the battle in photography - really learning how to look. now, the composition is the other vital element. they both come with much practice, and looking at other artwork.

well done, keep it up!

dog fight
by sevilduvarci

Comment:
o, o, o, sevil. thank you. how wonderful.

Frozen Staff
by notamartyr

Comment:
a fascinating and beautiful image.

Where's the Troll?
by jasonlprice

Comment:
a great image indeed. well done. the tones and subtlety are spot on. it's a good photograph, as well as 'meeting the challenge'. should have scored much higher.

Farris Wheel
by sabphoto

Comment:
a lovely image. the tension produced is superb.

Lava
by Kronus

Comment:
i really liked this one; hard to believe that something lit entirely with flourescent stuff could be subtle, but it is. you definitely deserved a better score.

Moments
by glad2badad

Comment:
fantastic image.