Lost at Sea
by noraneko

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club

What a joy to get this image to critique, although I'm not sure I'll be able to say much of anything helpful, it's such a beautiful image as it is. Here it goes :)

As a concept the image is great. It's a whimsical story, a little ladybug lost at sea, looking at the edge of the raft for a place to land. You could write a children's story-book about that. You pulled off the idea quite well. The title helps. Without the title, the idea would still come through clearly, but the title definitely helps.

As a composition, it's well done. Possibly the large black area in the centre is a bit too large, a bit too much dead space if you wish. It's hard to tell. I wonder if a hint of detail in all that black might work. The colour scheme is beautiful, very soothing (red/orange and green). The inline border is delicate, very appropriate to the image.

Technicals, the limitations of basic worked against you here :) However, it's possible that a bit of adjustment (either curves or S/H or maybe brightness) would do good for the image. The ladybug itself could be a bit brighter. Again, the black area could maybe have a bit of detail in it (watery detail?).

Does it meet the challenge? Yes, it does, there are bubbles in the image. It doesn't "sell" the concept of bubbles though, and that likely worked against you being top 10. It sells the story of a lost ladybug, the bubbles are somewhat incidental to that story, not main part.

I hope this helps. Any questions, complaints, whatever, feel free to contact me.

~Ursula

Why I'm Not Allowed in the Kitchen
by meyers

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club

I remember seeing this during the voting, and thinking, "Ewwwwwyyy!" I can so sympathize, I cut myself in the kitchen all the time, I'm really clumsy with knives.

Technicals:

Exposure/light looks right, your use of F4.5 gives enough clarity in the main subject while giving a soft blur to the context. The image is processed nicely, although I think I personally would prefer it without the red outer border (it looks a bit like overkill to me). Your main "technical" problem is that the blood doesn't look real, so you had trouble really selling the image. The back hand (the hand with the fake cut) looks a tad out of focus, and could be a bit sharper IMO.

From an artistic point of view, again, your choice of relatively shallow DOF works well with this composition. The composition itself is beautiful, there's enough context to give the image depth without clutter. The yellow/orange shadow is something I wonder about, I wonder if toning it down to a bit greyer would work. The apple being cut, it looks like two pieces in the hand, and the back piece looks like it is a bit too far back for it being cut realistically.

I am surprised at the score on this image - I would have thought it would score a fair bit higher than 4.5. I'm not sure what to tell you about that, except that it's hard to sell stuff to the DPC voters :) I think that the somewhat unreal feel of the photo hurt it quite a bit.

One little detail I love is the oof light spots on the blood in the sink. They make the blood look shiny wet, and that's a quirky little detail that I love.

I hope this helps.

~Ursula

A "high whisk" game of hide and seek...
by splidge

Comment:
Hello from the Critique Club

This is a beautiful image, very creative, it relies on a gentle hint for it's impact. It definitely meets the challenge. It also tells a story, a whimsical story at that, somewhat funny, somewhat scary - IMO this is wonderful photography.

From a technical point of view, I don't see anything wrong with it. The exposure is spot on, the colours are vibrant without being overdone, it is sharp without being oversharpened.

From an artistic point of view, the composition is very good, as is the presentation.

I'm trying to come up with something that might be helpful for you, and all I can think of is, "Keep up the good work!"

On Stand-By
by Jas

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club:

First of all, congratulations on your ribbon with this image :)

This is an excellent image, both technically and artistically. I am not sure that I can give you much useful information or advise, as it looks like you know quite well what you are doing here. So I'm going to try to approach this from a bit different point of view.

I remember when I first saw this in the challenge (during voting - I actually remember it). I thought, now here's one of the top 10 at least. Then I started thinking, wait a minute, something's off with the image, the right spoon (the spoon with the slot) looks bigger than the other, they should look the same! It still does, I'm not sure if that's an illusion or if it actually is bigger in the image. Anymore that illusion/reality sort of grew on me, I like it. I also really like it that the tops of the spoons are not the same.

This really is a well thought out and executed image. The only thing that I can think of to offer as a possible improvement (and that's very iffy) is that I wish the lettuce went across the whole of the bottom part - it sort of seems to peter out at the ends, especially the left side.

Congratulations again, and keep up the good work.

Rush Hour in the Swamp.jpg
by MelonMusketeer

Comment:
Wowzers! I've never seen anything like that. What a dangerous place you live in. We see bears on the road ocasionally, and the usual deer, moose, coyotes, turkeys, whatever. I've seen one (and only one) wolf by the road (no camera with me). But an alligator? That's special.

And a Canadian alligator would be really special :)

Go Forth and Multiply
by Rebecca

Comment:
Are you sure you want them to? :) Lovely tones to this image. I'm not entirely sure I like the focus, I sort of would like to see it on the little one ready to take off. ~8

Troy Bayliss
by Azrifel

Comment:
Excellent motion panning! ~9

Boots
by Tom_Robbrecht

Comment:
Best boots photo I've seen at DPC for a while! The border works great, increases the raggedy worn feel of the image. ~10

Going Home
by levyj413

Comment:
This works for me. The image could be really static, but with the person there, and with the blur of the person moving, it works. I like it that the building lines sort of flow towards the right, and the person, even though walking straight ahead, seems to be moving to the right a bit (the head). ~9

Fuchsia
by Sting11165

Comment:
Looks almost christmassy. Very beautiful. ~9