A Perfect Day for Gray
by Neil

Comment:
a shape of rocks among other shapes of rocks becomes your subject, existing only in your eye. how did you get the bird to be in the perfect location? I love the brief white of the foam; I love the sea disappearing into fog. 8

Wedged
by jgm5015

Comment:
ah, sweet mystery of the magic eight ball. it is as if you have captured a dream, only to leave it just beyond our reach. I love the shapes that reach up to the top of the frame and then veer away, confused. many directions going on here, to symbolize the ficklenes of the magic 8 ball. There is only one score I can give such a picture: 8

Where is the milk??
by Milacroft

Comment:
cat shape + bottle shape interacting directly yet missing each other. the bottle is deliriously sharp and wet, yet the cat is dark and fuzzy with enigma. great crop and composition. a delirious curvy diagonal takes the eye from top right to bottom left. 8.

My cat - Speedy
by broadwaybill

Comment:
I love the grain and the overexposed rectangles. 100 people are going to score you lower for this, but I am going to score you higher. Feel better? ;) the cat is wonderfully expressive, and the composition fits her perfectly into her geometry. 8

Violent Eruption
by GIS_boy

Comment:
beautiful. it looks like an eruption because the rock looks like it's only a shadow. layers of beach, ocean, rock, eruption, sky, cloud all build on one another to create what is actually a serene eruption. 9

Condimentary
by Jenga

Comment:
great eye. this is High Modernism, or somesuch. This should be hanging on MoMA's doorknob. 10

spot lights
by yoavb

Comment:
the world is your playset. it's only a cardboard sea. thank you for the magic that is photography. 10

hamburger stand
by undieyatch

Comment:
the lines of light take this picture into another realm. It's like a cartoon come to life, or life gone to cartoon. it is mysterious in the best possible way. 10

Shady Flower
by inanutshell

Comment:
great energetic demonic crazy shape. the grain just makes me feel like I'm in an old vampire movie. Halfway between Lugosi and Murnau. 8

peg legs
by Donald

Comment:
beautiful rays of darkness coming down, angled against the planks of wood. Terrific composition. 9