Stranger In A Strange Land
by BadPigg

Comment:
A lot of thought went into this one and it paid off. This is a really neat photo. It's a cutsey rather than a "wow" but I really like it. Nice humor and I needed that. I'd give you an 8 just for the lift it gave me. PTL

Stranger In A Strange Land
by goodtempo

Comment:
The building is beautiful and I love the bushes in front. That sure is a strange land beside. I still can't figure it out. Kinda looks like a reflection of some sort, but in what I'll never guess. This is strange and awesome. I like it and would give it an 8 if I could. PTL

Three Windows
by pstuhr

Comment:
This is a beautiful B&W, very clear and well focused. I like the cropping. My only thing is the angle. Did you mean to make it look like the whole building is leaning backwards and to the left side? Other than that I like it. 6

The Wall - Pink Floyd
by posthuman

Comment:
Looks like snow behind the wall. I like the vines growing on the wall. Courios as to where this wall is and why it's broken down, if it is. This may sound funny, but it is a beautiful wall. The stones are such beautiful color, so smooth, and make a nice pattern. Women notice things like that. Looks tall, or just the angel. I really like the photo and technically it is good: subject, focus, croping, light, clarity, etc. All good. Not a 10, because it's lacking "Wow" or "Pizazz" but you knew that. But it is an 8. PTL

Fly LIKE An Eagle
by Swashbuckler

Comment:
This is absolutely the most georgeous eagle and greatest photo that I have ever seen. This photo is deserving of honor and should be #1. The neck feathers are so awesome, you can almost feel the texture. The eye and the beak are.......It's like looking at the live bird in person. Wonderful photo and congratulations. It can hang on my wall any day. I'd love to give it a score of 100, but here's a 10 since that's all I'm allowed. PTL

These Boots Were Made for Walkin - Nancy Sinatra
by skippy

Comment:
They look used. You allow those on that light carpet? Meets the challenge. Good B&W. Good focus. Cropped a little close on the right. Not bad. 6 PTL

Purple Rain
by Jacko

Comment:
Beautiful purple but I'm trying to figure out the round thing in the middle. Technically I don't see the rain, just the steam on the window from it. Nice focus and crop. Border doesn't add a thing for me, and being black on the outside it detracts against the dark purple. I do like the rolls in the purple. Just can't figure out the round thing, unless it is just decoration on the shade or curtain. It's still a nice photo. PTL

Stairway to Heaven
by jjbeguin

Comment:
How is this a stairway to heaven? The tall tower on the left? It's a stretch but ok. Beautiful castle. But would have been so much better in color and I know there are a lot of others who will disagree with me. This castle is to beautiful not to show it in it's fullness, color and all. Good sharp focus and nice cropping. In color I'd give it a 9. In B&W it's a 7 to me. PTL

"American Pie"
by LindaE

Comment:
Love the song and love how you portrayed it. Looks like cherry pie and that is very American. Shame you couldn't use a baseball in the theme. Good shot. Personally I don't think the extra area on the right was necessary but it doesn't hurt it for me either. Just a little bright but good shot. It's an 8 to me. PTL

These Boots Are Made For Walkin'
by vestanpance

Comment:
And look like they have, a lot. I like how they are nice and black at the tops and become very worn at the toes. Shows a lot of wear and use. I like your choice of background. Just a little bright for me, maybe a little less contrast would help that. But good B&W. 7 PTL