Simplicity
by adiputra

Comment:
Love the title and it fits the challenge real well. Love the background and choice of single flower. Great shot. Real good techs. Straight 8. PTL

Metal Rose
by jab119

Comment:
Great metal rose. Almost looks real. Would have prefered you not crop the edges off. Would like to have seen it all. Soft focus is good on this. In my opinion the only thing that hurt it is the crop. That cropped off 2 points for an 8. PTL

Huevos
by Rfarias

Comment:
Don't know what these are. For all I know they could be dinasourse eggs. But there are good and sharp. A good B & W. The details in each one of them is very clear and distinct. Would like to know what they are. The photo is a good 7 in quality. PTL

sweeeet!!!
by rayala

Comment:
Beautiful moth. Great picture. Great croping. Technically it's a 10 except for, in my opinion, a little dark on the background, but don't know that you could do much on that inside the rules. Guess I'll give th 10. PTL

Which Came First?
by emorgan49

Comment:
Too much light on the back side. Not enough light below the egg. Otherwise real great. Looks like he's not complete dry after being born - the tip of his wing looks wet. I call that perty good photo. at least an 8. PTL

Watching Metal Dance
by Krozar

Comment:
almost an aperstan. Lacks "wow" Crop should have included all of something, maybe the circular part. Maybe closer on the right as I look at it. Still a good 6. PTL

The DIY Arsenal
by Manic

Comment:
Clear, sharp and to the point. Good background choice for the color of the bits. Good Techs. Lacks "wow" but good quality photography. A solid 8. PTL

Ut Ohhhh
by willie55

Comment:
Wish you couldn't see the hand holding it. Soft focus but that's not bad here. Shouldn't have cropped the top so closely. That would have added. Still a 7. Was initially going to give it a 5 or 6, but it worked on me. PTL

it foams marine
by saulo

Comment:
Maybe I need my son to explain this one to me. He is a marine. But I can't see what it is except a lot of foam. My imagination suggests several things but I'm not going there. Without knowing "what" it is and just scoring the whatever it is a solid 5 technically. PTL

Fly Away Home
by Kaz

Comment:
ONLY THING WRONG - you should have cropped out the whole right side as I look at it. The wing covers lifted with the wings stopped in action - these are things you just don't get except.... once in a life time.. Even the "V", "G". and "B" are in great focus. You should have come in on the bug. Wouldn't stay in focus? It's still a good solid 8. PTL