Greenhouse Effect
by cloudsme

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club. First let me state you met the challenge well. I like the leading lines, and I think the centering works pretty well on this shot. I wish the leading lines would lead me to a point of interest, or off into the sunset so to speak, instead it leads me to a woman. I almost wish it had been in color though. The flowers hanging from the ceiling make the photo just a bit too busy for me. Overall its a nice challenge entry and scored just about where I would have expected. Good luck in future challenges.

Serenity Found
by idnic

Comment:
I dont know if its a bad illusion but to me the photo seems like it has a horizon problem. The more I look at it the more I think its an optical illusion but when I look at the fountain I find my head tilting slightly to the left to get a feel of being straight. I like the composition and the lighting is a nice effect. I just dont know about having the "feeling" of needing to tilt left.

Ducks Play Lightly
by sfalice

Comment:
Greetings from the critique club. First I'd like to point out that I'm pretty sure this specimen is a goose not a duck. That may have been a problem with the voters. I like the good focus, lighting and the use of OoF background Bokeh to bring the viewer to the title and to the Subject. I think what really hurt you was the fact that you had the wrong animal for the title. Good luck in future challenges.

DSCN5560_new.jpg
by Nowaytotell

Comment:
Decent lighting, pretty good exposure my gosh they dont look old enough to be married. I must be getting old!

DSCN5570_new.jpg
by Nowaytotell

Comment:
This looks a bit oversharpened and over neat imaged. Do you have an unedited version we can see maybe some PP tips might help save it.

One Tree Hill
by Rebecca

Comment:
I love this, it reminds me of Windows XP default backgound! Nice colors and composition.

Determined
by drewyramone

Comment:
Greetings from teh critique club. Let me start by saying you met the challenge. I feel the colors are a bit too saturated on this shot. And way too much depth of field. I noticed you shot @ F16 you need to shoot wide open in your case with that lens F4 so you can try and isolate your subject from the background there is nothing in the background that I need to see that adds to the photo. Also waiting a bit to get closer to the peak action, what we see here is just the beginning of the action. OVerall pretty good challenge entry. Good luck in future challenges.

A wedding photoshoot in a very public place
by NalaAndTroy

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique club. First let me welcome you to DPC with your first challenge entry. Now on to the critique. First let me remind you to always take advantage of the largest size available for any challenge. In this case 640 pixels on the largest side. Here is a link to the critique.

Tutorial

Next thing make sure that when you have an entry to make sure you crop out unwanted/needed things. In other words crop out just what you want us to see as your subject. Take the stuff on the bottom, top, left and right that dont add to the photo.

The colors that I can see from the small size look good.

Overall you have some room for improvement but hopefully I've helped you get that start.

About Rugby (In Dresses)
by boxImmortal

Comment:
Greetings from the critique club. First off nice take on the challenge. Its definately sports, although definately a different take on it. I like the stopped action on the ball and the players. Def very close to peak action. The play coming at you is def nice. My biggest fault of this photo seems to be thats its too busy. There are too many things in the photo to take my attention. I think I might have preferred a very tight crop to lose the stuff on the left that doesnt offer much to the photo. I might also liked to have seen just a touch more USM after resizing to sharpen it up a touch. Overall nice challenge entry.

Almost symmetric
by korpen

Comment:
Greetings from the critique club. First let me say that I love the colors, background, the texture and the simplicity of this shot. Its a simple subject usually not doing so well on DPC but the take you have on this has set well with the voters. I think I might have bumped the saturation and the USM levels on this just a bit. Otherwise you did very well on this shot. Scored about where I would have in the challenge had I voted on it.