Better Stalk Up, Winter's Comin' Soon...
by bs-photos

Comment:
I gave this a 4. Whilst the focus seems good, as well as a good ground up perspective, there wasn't enough overall depth (as in 'feel'), in my opinion. Perhaps a variation in toning may have given this a little extra, not sure. edit:removed 'TN'

Message edited by author 2006-08-21 15:23:31.

I will Survive
by tuffy

Comment:
9 - Very nice. The only thing I think may make this even better, is if the grass/seed head were entirely in front of the horse's head - as in totally 'framed' - but.. minor. Perhaps a little sharper too on that said grass, but again minor and - likely there just unable to be appreciated at this size. Lastly, to really 'nit-pick', your title all capitalized too would make this even more professional - in my opinion.

The Pavilion
by Chilibean

Comment:
7 - Really like this. Your call (obviously), but in this case, I think this may have worked even better 'toned'.

Doorway
by speeding_slowly

Comment:
8 - Really like this. Excellent sharp angle/perspective. Toning works very well. Undecided if more detail discernable (sharper focus, as seems to be on the door fixture) in the metal(?) texture on the doorknob/handle may have given this a little extra - but may have changed the 'abstractness', so who knows.

let's go fly a kite
by mimsydotes

Comment:
8 - Like the focal point. Nice simple clothing which works well with the tones. Difficult, but just a litle more 'pop'/detail on the kite and possibly (depending what you had to work with of course), a fraction more room at the top of the frame, especially so the top of the child's hair wasn't cropped - but fairly minor.

Jacob's Ladder
by SJCarter

Comment:
8 - Symmetry seems spot on. Toning works well. Your call (obviously), but wonder whether rotated left may have packed more punch, not sure.

The Window
by bucket

Comment:
9 - Excellent image. Not much to 'suggest', maybe the staircase railing cropped out, but unlikely - looks near perfect to me. I want to say a whisker of a nudge rotate up on the left - but I think it is just a visual thing. The b&w works so well. Up to 9 from 8.

Perched in Endless Skies
by Cutter

Comment:
8 - Very nice. Excellent sky/cloud capture, especially for whatever processing under basic.

All dogs go to heaven?
by mayonesa

Comment:
8 - Good angle/perspective. Fairly minor, but in my opinion, this would be even better with a nudge rotate up on the left to get the shingles/tiles 'straight'. The darker areas around the snout and eyes with a little more light, but difficult - and again, fairly minor.

Windstopper
by jansku

Comment:
8 - Nice, clean and simple.