Coca-cola
by gonoGM

Comment:
I think the post processing made the image too painted looking.

A hard earned thirst...needs a big cold beer...VIC BEER!
by Judi

Comment:
Except for the title, this shows no product. Number one rule in advertising, you need to show the product somewhere. As a black and white, your contrast is very good with plenty of lights and darks.

Meagre Selection
by mattisokay

Comment:
Very good concept. Saw one like this on a billboard, so you did a fine job of depicting it in a way the advertising market would jump on. I know it is basic editing, so spot editing is not allowed, but the overexposed line at the bottom is distracting. Still, overall, you used dramatic lighting to highlight the product. 8

Cool. Smooth. Refreshing.
by SJCarter

Comment:
I love the concept of this one. A bit more crop to focus more on the product would have really brought it out better. It is the product you are selling, not the background. 8

Illuminatis™
by gloda

Comment:
Very cool. Not sure how you did it, but I will check when challenge is over. The only thing I wonder about is why there is no product name on the label. Since it is an ad, I think that might have been an important point.

Privacy Please
by Diana

Comment:
Oh, this was so underrated. I can't believe it placed where it did. I feel your pain on this one. It was a terrific image, though I did read one comment that said a bit more crop might have helped, but still, definitely a great capture.

Gothic Bondage
by Physics_Guru

Comment:
I gave this one a 7, but am not surprised at the score of this one. It really doesn't jive with dp narrowmindedness. Anyway, I have a goth living in my house, so I thought your image was well done. Too bad it didn't do better.

Mirage
by LevT

Comment:
Very nice technique in post processing. I like the black and white foreground and the colored island in the distance. Nice subject, too. Warm and fuzzy.

Sittin' by the Dock of the Bay
by alanfreed

Comment:
Love the sky treatment on this one. Just beautiful image.

Laundry Basket
by Bear_Music

Comment:
I like the orange contrast on this one. It made an interesting reflection in the plastic beads. The overall effect is lacking in contrast, though. The orange gave it some zip, but not enough.