Maple Fall
by blad

Comment:
There is some issues with the sharpness of this image. I believe this image can meet the challenge description as well as the definition of minalism. Artisticlly you delt with the image well within the four side of the frame. You would have scored a perfect 10 if it were not four the sharpness issues as stated. Not sure if it is focusing or noise etc.

Blue Sky
by telma

Comment:
Okay I know I am being picky...but why in the world did you title this "Blue Sky".. What you title your images is what you want the viewer to believe your main subject is. I believe you subject as defined by the challenge description is suppose to be the smallest part of your image. That being said I won't judge you by your title......:-)

Meets challenge description.....................10
Meets definition of minimalism...................10
Technical....................................................9 not sure if it is my screen or the image but there appears to be noise or artifacts in it.
Artistic........................................................5 I don't know why this image is not placed more to the center of the photograph.

Average score 8

Cruisin, USA
by bearbear

Comment:
As a collector of VW diecast I love this image.

meets challenge description.....................10
meets definition of minimalism.....................6
Technical....................................................6 seems to me that there is some artacts in the image around the toy
Artistic.......................................................8

Average score..............................................7

Dead Bug
by arsharif

Comment:
technical problems need to be corrected......Bug is not in focus and there is nose in the image.

First Base
by L1

Comment:
No further comment is need......................10

Shot Gun Smoke Ring
by sofap

Comment:
Don't like the shape of the frame. 9

Raindrops
by om10

Comment:
Meet description of challenge............10
Meets definition of Minimalism.............10
Technical.............................................10
Artistic...................................................6

Average score......................................9

"Jaune"
by bell

Comment:
Meets challenge discription....................................0
Meets definition of Minimalism................................10
Technical................................................................9 some artifacts or noise
Artistic....................................................................10 I like this image. It speak of hang cloth in the simplist of terms......color works nicely with the black.

Average score.............................7

Hidden
by Mr_Pants

Comment:
Meets description of challenge............5 becuase the background is so busy and demands your attention before you see the animal...
Meets the definition of Minimalism.........5 the image speaks about the bushes in a more direct manor
Technical................................................6
Artistic.....................................................6
Average score...........................................................5

Water Bird
by John Snider

Comment:
Meets challenge description...........10
Meets definition of minimalism...........5
Technical...........................................5
Artistic...............................................5 without title there is no voice heard from
this image

Average score 6