Convergence in steel
by arpita

Comment:
Excellent image! Great POV, DOF, Composition, tones, great everything! 10 from me - good luck in the challenge!

1910 Western Pacific Caboose Handbreak
by fulgent

Comment:
simple, elegant, great tones. Composition and crop well done. Variety of textures enhances image. 10 - good luck in the challenge!

Metal Pipes
by Mircea

Comment:
Wow - this is cool! Not sure if a darker backgorund would work better here. You have lights and darks in the subject but I believe a darker background may have made the shiny pop. Excellent composition, crop, DOF, POV. 9 from me - Good luck in the challenge!

Cold Metal
by agfoto

Comment:
Wow. Very shiny. :) The textures in this image work well. The smooth against the mottled background is great! The balance in this composition is excellent - good crop. Focus, DOf, POV all well done. 9 - good luck in the challenge!

Scoops and Nails
by artvet

Comment:
I love the tones and the textures in this image. Composition seems just a bit awkward but I'm not used to looking at things from straight over head. The white on the right is a little harsh to my eye. Focus is great. Honestly, I'm torn. I want to give you a 6 for POV and highlight but I want to give you an 8 for tones, mood, and texture. Okay, 8 it is. Good luck in the challenge!

That eBay Photo
by Konador

Comment:
you get a 10 from me. I'm not even going to elaborate. Just take the 10.

Chevrolet
by Man_Called_Horse

Comment:
keep going back and forth - B&W? COLOR? B&W? COLOR? The world may never know. Like this image. Composition and crop work for me. 6 - may bump later...

St.Louis Welcomes You
by sacredspirit

Comment:
If this image were mine, I would have cropped a little off the bottom and made the border smaller. Just a different point of view. Color, clarity, DOF, POV all excellent. 7 - good luck in the challenge!

Meat and Metal
by bvoi

Comment:
okay. I'm hungry now. Argh! Great take on the challenge. Tasty looking food! 7

Woodshed
by DeniseBernadette

Comment:
Really like this image. Reminds me of a painting. Like to see it without the stumps in the lower right. They pull my eye out of the rest of the image. Not sure removing them would be an improvement though - just a thought.