A secret world
by marian

Comment:
Very nice. It does seem like a hidden, enchanted place. A miniature palace, maybe. 7.

the One
by valiooo

Comment:
This is a great bird shot because of the wonderful morphing of the tree and the bird. The one becomes the other, with barely a visible junction. Consider the legs of the bird, versus the slim branches lower down; such a lovely echo. It's a wildlife shot for grownups because it's about so much more than the bird. 9.

Stern
by jay6850

Comment:
Superb. Lots of Henry Fonda, which is apt because it's a wonderfully theatrical portrait in terms of lighting, positioning and his orientation not for the camera, but for some unseen, probably imaginary audience. 8.

Father & Son
by philcozz

Comment:
All that repetition, all those related shapes of lights, railcars, windows; all replicas of each other. And a father and son. That's just right! 8.

BW Me 2
by ScooterMcNutty

Comment:
Yes. That is what I was trying to say. And the reason I used the word 'reductive' to describe it is because it is more usual for people of your age to want to do the opposite; to elaborate and embellish (clothes, piercing, tattoos, gestures, all that stuff). No so many feel secure enough to depict themselves so frankly, without all those props. So I congratulate you both on the lovely photograph and the confident self-image. I was an idiot when I was 15. I'd have done all the stuff Jason mentioned. Probably worse than that. Of course, I was also a guy.

by nixter

Comment:
When you're a child, moments sometimes seem to last longer. Seconds, minutes, hours, forever.
Sublime moment, Nick.

Life Unpretty
by RKT

Comment:

Originally posted by undieyatch: ... "Do not go gentle into that good night. Rage, rage against the dying of the light."

Yes.

Apocalyptica
by cmtc

Comment:
cytoxan is quite correct; I am a lot older than you and so there's likely to be a communication gap between us. I gave it a 5, which is well above average for me (my average in this challenge was about 4.0 I think). My comment during voting was that it is a nicely-made photograph but of no apparent substance beyond that. Tattoo + armpit + gas mask ... presumably it's a combination that must mean something? Unless of course its point is to not have one. Alas, nobody (including you) has given we crusty old dudes any hint as to its meaning. Nevertheless, it was well inside my top 20% in the challenge.

Old School
by gsal

Comment:
I'm sick of you now. You're so last month.

- only kidding, I still love ya.

BW Me 2
by ScooterMcNutty

Comment:
It's very frank, this self-portrait. Reductive. I know you're a couple of generations younger than me, but I hope you won't think it patronizing if I say that I am surprised to find that level of restraint in one so (relatively) young. It's a very lovely, assured portrait.