Rebel Yell
by umbris

Comment:
You didn't need to take rebel apart to get yourself a ribbon...

Composition: Something is bothering me about it, probably a lack of focal point. The circles (from the EF mount?) could have been used to accentuate a recognizeable object in this mess, for example, the 'digital rebel' logo on the front of the case. Just a suggestion.
Challenge: The image meets and exceeds the assigned topic.
Overall, 8.

Eggbert meets the frying pan
by LalliSig

Comment:
Funny, to me it looks like this egg is vomiting. I wish the egg color was more realistic (on the yellow side)

Broken pipe
by blanceric

Comment:
Too busy surroundings... if the pipe was more closely cropped, this could have been better.

In need of Wagon Repair Man
by puma

Comment:
I like the composition. The top-left area of the sky seems too bright, could have been toned down a bit, perhaps.

The Dogs Broke Me
by eaglebeck

Comment:
I think that the scoreboard was sufficient. Big red letters saying :Racing form" just take the attention away from the wallet

The Way to Her Heart
by librodo

Comment:
Very nice idea. The rose & the nose are slightly overexposed, and that ruins it for me. only a 6 for this one. (revised upwards on a second run-through)

If you come to the Kitimat River Bridge, you've gone to far.
by spiller

Comment:
I like this one, especially since I suspect that no desaturation was needed for this shot, and yet the color of the bridge is outstanding. I'm not sure how much of a busy street this is, but I would have preferred if you'd taken this shot from the middle of the road. That way you might have avoided that puddle on the right that is just a distraction.

Golden Reflections
by Albireo

Comment:
That light reflection is disturbing otherwise very good image.

Fresh from farm
by gaurawa

Comment:
I have mixed feelings about the drops of water. I am not sure if I can explain it - but it seems to me that the waterdrops don't go with the frame. Either the drops or the frame, but not both.

Primary Swimmer
by dartompkins

Comment:
Great capture. Although the tail is a bit soft on focus, the eye... I have a feeling that this fish is looking straight at me! 8!