Aucun Titre
by L2

Comment:
Composition: 8 - Bit too much space at the top imo, but other than that, great!
Technical: 9 - Perfect exposure, perfect processing, perfect lighting. The only thing that bothers me a bit is the few yellowy patches around the shoulder. A localized hue/sat adjustment should help :)
Creativity: 8 - Nice dynamic pose makes it more than just a normal portrait shot.
Appeal: 10 - The great photo along with the attractive model gives this top marks for appeal :)

Overall Calculated Average Score: 9

A Boy And His Castle
by CNovack

Comment:
Composition: 5 - Good, but too much black at the bottom imo.
Technical: 5 - Nice exposure on the sky but there is actually some detail in the silhouette which I find distracting. Not enough to see it properly, but enough to stop it looking like a proper silhouette. Brightness/Contrast in PS would help make it darker, and also make the sky more vibrant.
Creativity: 6 - I like how the castle is almost as tall as him! :)
Appeal: 5 - Not an awful lot here to hold my interest for long, sorry.

Overall Calculated Average Score: 5

Guest star... Roy Hargrove
by alexgarcia

Comment:
Composition: 9 - Almost perfect, the right shoulder touching the frame is the only distraction
Technical: 9 - Again, almost perfect. I'd have liked it a little brighter in the highlights
Creativity: 6 - Not the most unique angle but the closeup and the background are good
Appeal: 9 - I really like this shot :)

Overall Calculated Average Score: 8

She Waits
by missinseattle

Comment:
Composition: 7 - Really nice, not quite centered but not quite following the generic "rules" - works well!
Technical: 6 - I like the soft focus and the high key but its a shame the hat blends into the sky.
Creativity: 6 - I like that it poses questions such as where is she going, and what is she looking at?
Appeal: 6 - Could add appeal by adding a slight sepia tint, really subtly, just to add some warmth. The B&W just seems a bit cold and uninteresting.

Overall Calculated Average Score: 6

Bird of Prey
by jimika

Comment:
Composition: 5 - I'd have liked some extra space of the left for it to "look into"
Technical: 5 - There is some overexposure on the head and I think the background would add more impact if it were darker.
Creativity: 4
Appeal: 5

Overall Calculated Average Score: 5

GHOSTLY Wreck
by dmadden

Comment:
Composition: 7 - I think it needs a little more space at the top, just a little.
Technical: 8 - Love the long exposure to make the water look mystical, the exposure is perfect too
Creativity: 7 - Great colours and choices you've made.
Appeal: 7 - Great shot overall

Overall Calculated Average Score: 7

Tentville
by Patrol

Comment:
Composition: 6 - I'd have liked to see a bit more of the forground and less sky.
Technical: 6 - Slight blown out bits in the sky and a slight lack of some foreground detail. It adds to the mood, yes, but I just feel I'd like to see a little more detail.
Creativity: 6 - Nice unique landscape shot with all of whats happening on the ground.
Appeal: 6

Overall Calculated Average Score: 6

Barney at window
by lyta

Comment:
Composition: 6 - Nice to have him looking into the frame with good negative space on the right
Technical: 5 - Nice and sharp, well exposed, but there seems to be grey splotches and stuff in the background from editing, is your monitor calibrated?
Creativity: 4 - Not really anything unique about the shot.
Appeal: 3

Overall Calculated Average Score: 4

steam
by arngrimur

Comment:
Composition: 10 - Perfect
Technical: 10 - Perfect
Creativity: 10 - Perfect
Appeal: 10 - Exactly the type of photo which I love :)

Overall Calculated Average Score: 10

Up Hill
by shudderbug

Comment:
Composition: 8 - Works really well with just enough negative space and the cyclist in a perfect position
Technical: 6 - Nicely exposed, but I feel like it needs just a bit more saturation. The colours look a bit muted when really in this shot I think they'd look great really really colourful.
Creativity: 6 - Nicely done, I like the fact it looks like he's cycling up for no reason other than to come back down :)
Appeal: 6

Overall Calculated Average Score: 6