Goodbye, my Love...
by pikwol

Comment:
I am sure you would disagree or you wouldn't have entered the photo in this challenge, but IMO DNMC.

Focused
by JPetraliaX

Comment:
I am sure you would disagree or you wouldn't have entered the photo in this challenge, but IMO DNMC.

staples
by ralph

Comment:
Fantastic photo. Love the DOF and the lighting. Composition is super. Powerful contrast. Unfortunately DNMC.

What did I do wrong?
by sarsonuk

Comment:
The lighting is flat and sepia toned. Was this a conscious choice? Greater contrast and multiple light sources would address the flat light. I am in awe of the models' ability to hold perfectly still for 30 seconds or more. But in the end I'm not resonating with the photo. Guess you didn't get lucky w/ me, either.

On the Can
by danthesquidkid

Comment:
I gave this a low score because you captured 3 of my photographic pet peeves in one photo: tilted towel bar; poor focus, and a toilet. It does show a sense of humor ... best we not take ourselves too seriously.

The Pause That Refreshes
by anaheimca89

Comment:
I am prepared to believe this was a 30 second exposure. It is technically well done and the degree of difficulty is fairly high. But in the words of Pinky and the Brain ...

Brain, "Pinky, are your pondering what I'm pondering?"
Pinky, "Well I thinks so Brain, but a Coke bottle for a subject? What would Mr. Adams think?"

Alien landing
by justamistere

Comment:
Looks like a Christmas tree on acid. Interesting but not to my (current) taste.

Quit Staring At It!!!!
by buzzrock

Comment:
Just my opinion. Poor photo with a title in poor taste.

Psychogenic Incorporeality
by blackenedwhite

Comment:
You succeeded in creating an emotional response in me. I don't want to be here, that's for sure. You hint at a story (which I like). Why is this person here? For how long? Why is he (she?) wearing a wedding ring? I can see this in Newsweek or Time, or some such. I think the title diminishes the photo. You could have used the title to continue to tell the story.

The Soul of a Warrior
by posthumous

Comment:
A great photo occurs when a great subject combines with great execution. In this case the execution is fine, but the subject does nothing for me. It's not that it's a bad photo, but rather a photo of a subject I don't want to look at. I am sure this sounds negative. Sorry.