Dark Water
by zeuszen

Comment:
I chose not to watch this movie, I wasn't interested in the storyline and from viewing this image I believe I made the right choice. Here I see a body of water with a reflection that I personally find unappealing. Also, by seeing the stones through the water it does not seem all that deep thus eliminating the credibility of the title.

The Lord of the Rings
by breadfan35

Comment:
I enjoy the clarity of this version better than the last I saw. However, I also enjoy the way the eyes and ring stood out on the other one. I feel a bit more pop in the eyes and ring would have really made this a strong image. The green wrap and hair work out nicely.

"We have a 'product' on the loose" (The Island)
by Mephisto

Comment:
I am not familiar with this scene. It is very clean looking, and the separations and reflections are interesting. But not knowing exactly what you are trying to show it makes it difficult to understand.

Down Came a Blackbird
by pointandshoot

Comment:
no idea what this is, but I enjoy the textures and depth. The single light source fading to black is nice. Now, as I continue to look at this image I see a couple birds flying, easily missed and I feel does not hold strong enough to give me a sense of what you are trying to portray

The Lord of the Rings
by aerogurl

Comment:
Maybe a bit to small, but the first of the several in the challenge that I am viewing full size. I do enjoy how the eyes and the ring pop out in the image, but not sure about the soft/blur and the hand appears a bit disjointed as well.

The Children of the Marshland
by jjbeguin

Comment:
I am not familiar with the movie, however to me, this seems like just a snapshot at a pond. With the smog one would be let to think this is suppose to be a 'scary' type of movie? However, I feel it isn't very strong.

They're heeere! (Poltergeist)
by DrAchoo

Comment:
Classic Horror, have to give an extra point for that. I enjoy the concept, but for me it just seems to smooth running down her back and across the floor in the reflection. I think maybe its a bit too bright on her jumper.

300
by Ivory

Comment:
What a fun costume and the clouds work well. However the model doesn't seem to portray Spartan as much as I would have liked to see.

Fight Club
by labuds

Comment:
Pretty fun image, I think if it was a bit more gritty it would have been a lot stronger. To me, it just seems to smooth and clean.

Because of Winn Dixie
by MaryO

Comment:
I don't know anything about Winn Dixie, but 'The Shaggy Dog' rings a bell. I would have preferred a bit more depth to this image. it feels a bit flat, and the blurred area around the nose is distracting.