Trees within
by Gaia

Comment:
Not sure I can make out the window.

The Shining Crescent
by tyt2000

Comment:
There are a few artifacts, and I wonder why this isn't color, but this is great composition. -7

through beveled glass
by muckpond

Comment:
I'm guessing that the time of year (late winter/early spring) made B&W the right choice for this shot with no leaves on the tress, no green to be found. So, take this for what it is worth: I am left thinking that this would have been stronger in color. Given the B&W choice, a little extra contrast would have helped on the house to the left. All that aside, the beveled glass was a great choice for the challenge. -6

Evening View from Kitchen
by scottwilson

Comment:
Great sunset and certainly hammers the challenge, but the composition would have been much better if you had moved your grill, the towel(s) and soap.

It Is Finished
by jpochard

Comment:
I wasn't sure I liked the color choice, and the shutter speed could have been a little faster (looks like a little motion in the shepard behind the crosses) but I liked almost everything else. The depth of field choice in particular was very good as I can see emotion on all the faces.

FWIW: I don't think this is really chaos, but it didn't matter, as I thought it was a great subject for Easter week. FWIW: I scored it a 6.

Rusty
by eikidigi

Comment:
That looks more like a gear to me, but I really like the lighting and colors, so who cares. A little sharper on the rust would have helped a little.

Analog Flight Computer
by Dr.Confuser

Comment:
Interesting subject, and very well done. Small improvements in DOF and lighting (cutting the overexposure on the highlights) might be possible. But, I definately like this. -9

Old reliable
by adjsas

Comment:
Too small.

Wheels in a discarded printer
by kposey

Comment:
Those are really gears, not wheels, but it is an interesting picture. Looks like it might be a bit oversharpened.

Wheels Galore
by JACKIE BIRD

Comment:
Too small to really evaluate.