One Down ~ Three to Go
by Ja-9

Comment:
go, go go.... charming

windows windows windows
by tvsometime

Comment:
well seen the clean confusion of our times - excellent minimal ed'g

Contour
by Cuttooth

Comment:
a world in itself this image, excellent

Burned match
by hajeka

Comment:
I marked it with 8.
Lovely

good-bye
by posthumous

Comment:
My mark (oh yes, it's important!) was a 9 only because the silly ipad did not register the bump to 10.
It's part of my favorite shots.
Again, my mind went to Tarkovsky, and my reading was way more gentle than I read in other comments. It has to do with paving the road, with family ties, with the clearing in the forest and a slew of other symbolic elements. Life itself

Lord of the flies
by nygold

Comment:
Excellent for the book and a powerful image in its own right. I like how the boys become one with the wild nature. The ribs are like the frowzled background
8 (for now)
I am quite haunted by the look of these boys.
9

The Sun Also Rises
by Marfun

Comment:
Nice landscape, delicate but falls short for this challenge and it seems just chosen to suit the title of the novel but not its content that has so much more to say.
There is a surfeit of sunsets and sunrises in photography and we all try our hands to capture them but they shall be shown sparingly for more effect.
5

"North and South," by John Jakes
by ShaneBlake

Comment:
Did not read the novel and I believe that this reenactment is as accurate as it could be but the picture does not inspire me much in terms of a good photograph. Could be a good as reference photo.
5

Charlotte's Web
by DanaS

Comment:
This shot is definitely less suitable for the radiance of the novel. I do not like to see here the rear end of this creature that seems in search of food instead of weaving a marvel for our amazement.
5 for the effort

The Prophet
by jagar

Comment:
I think that there are here too many elements - some quite beautiful such as the crouched silhouette, but a little confusing. There is something that does not attract me here, as I was not attracted to read the book (yet).
5