Fire in the Sky
by Yo_Spiff

Comment:
Looks like I was off with my guess about this ribbon-ing. Oh well :)
Still a good score though. And I don't regret giving it a 9 either.

Night Time Moon bow
by mgarsteck

Comment:
I'm glad you said 'moon bow' because it looks like day time! The star trails prove it isn't and I'd've missed them had you not titled it such. Good work.
I know it's night time so the sky is very blue, but I find it a little too blue considering the rest of the shot looks like it's day time. I might have done some selective editing on that region. But either way wonderful shot, and you're getting an 8.

thought process
by smardaz

Comment:
I guess it's a criticism you might have anticipated, but I don't like where the subject is looking. I don't feel engaged with him at all.
Lighting is excellent. Really excellent. Tiny bit of white on the bottom right that I don't like too much. But besides that well done!

follow
by posthumous

Comment:
Nearly a 'the running' iii? :)
I like this. Very moody. the tones and lighting mean you don't see everything until you stare at it for a while.

Set the "Way Back Machine" to 1942, Sherman
by Dr.Confuser

Comment:
Superb image! Love it. Nice lighting on the bottom.

eco awareness
by william88

Comment:
Man, this is nice. Nice concept and title. I'm wondering if I'm way out in asking if this is from another collaboration with 'Brian'...

Face2Face
by MAK

Comment:
I really like this, except for the title :)
A bit of extra light on the right eye would have made me a little happier I think. But I like the centred and face-on composition. 7 from me. I likes :)

Emerging from Morning Fog
by MargaretNet

Comment:
I've only looked at 17 images so far, but this is spectacular. I reckon you have a high probability of being close to a ribbon with this image. There's no doubt in my mind who this is either. Might get your fourth ribbon. And with a free study too!

Jamie
by fotomann_forever

Comment:
Well deserved score and ribbon. I'm not always a fan of your work but from processing to lighting to the tones to desaturation to the pose was really something.
No cheese though?:-)

vintage two
by bspurgeon

Comment:
One of my favourites of the challenge. Gorgeously lit and grain is wonderful too.