Gated Beauty
by channeled

Comment:
I would have taken it from a different angle, so that the fence could have got mor echaracter. Indeed beautiful, I love the colours. :-)

Blurring the boundaries
by robsmith

Comment:
Very good idea, but indeed blurry... This could be a very effective photo if you had made it with a prisma and lights! What about trying it?

Christmas Wish
by Paclo

Comment:
Unique idea, and excellent lighting! Your choose of subject is simply amazing! I like the background transition from white to black, too. One of my few 10s in this challenge, my pick for a ribbon! :-)

Set the limit!
by kinks

Comment:
This is my favourite in this challenge. :-) Excellent composition, unique idea and great use of DOF, meets the challenge well. Good luck! :-)

Will you give to charity?
by Samara

Comment:
Good idea, on the edge of keeping or giving it to charity! :-) I would have used a homogenic dark background and money could be a bit more in focus, otherwise I like the unique idea here.

Edgemaker
by billieb

Comment:
The photo is grainy and the wide white border on the right and bottom are very distracting. The lighting on the metal is good! No blow outs anywhere.

Skating on thin Ice!
by train

Comment:
Excellent idea and composition, I like the skate slipping on the edge, and your original title fits the challenge, too! Left side of the skate metal could be more in focus, maybe crop is too tight on the left. I am hesitating between 8 and 9, but I love the idea and all so much that I give you the 9. :-) Happy Holidays and photograph a lot. :-)

Leaning Pine
by Beagleboy

Comment:
Is it on the edge of falling into the river? Very creative idea, I also love the silouettes and the background having a foggy feeling, and a wonderful nature photo! White border is not even on the sides, it's narrower on the right. Take 9 from me.

cigarettes
by juanangel55

Comment:
Good idea, makes me think about it in a literal way, too. The scratch on the edge of the table(?) is a bit distracting and background is busy for my personal taste, too (removing the objects or shallower DOF would have helped, I think so). The ash-tray could be sharper, too, though the composition of it is good!

Dividing the Shot
by Melly8522

Comment:
I like the diagonal composition, anyway it could be sharper, this way it's a bit blurry. Maybe I would have more "divided" apart" feeling if you had added some subjects to the both sides, just an idea and matter of personal taste.