Wake Up Call
by MsAmbrosia

Comment:
I really like the idea--but I think it needed to be processed more. Overall, it seems very dark. I think there could be much more in the highlights and contrast. Also, the depth of field seems very short. I don't mind the lower left out of focus, but since the category is sound, having the right bell so fuzzy seems distracting

Nature's Alarm Clock
by chickadeezl

Comment:
I only have a very short time to score this category. I just wanted you to know that I scored this a 7, but as soon as I clicked the button to go to the next screen, this picture called me back. I'm moving it to a 9 just because it made me come back for a second look. Not many picture make you rethink yourself.

"SPLASH"
by dhumann1

Comment:
spectacular! 10

Breaking the Sound Barrier
by bicklevov

Comment:
I think I would have liked this cropped in more. I really wanted to see the detail in the smoke, and the foreground and extra sky seem unnecessary.

Speaker Cone
by pheonix676

Comment:
I don't care for the shot, but I do appreciate the interesting angle of the shot. I rated it higher than I wanted to because of the angle.

Sound of steel
by familydobes

Comment:
I'm sorry, it doesn't compare well against similar shots.

uuaa-uuaa-uuaa...
by LevT

Comment:
I'm sorry, I only have a limited time to judge and comment on this category, and unfortunately, I could be having an early senior moment, but I can't figure out what it is... I hope I have time to come back later and give it a second glance--but you might want to find a way to make it a little more recognizable on first glance. 4

w a i t i n g
by Jessi

Comment:
I like this very much. I'm afraid that some people will look at the picture and wonder "silence?" But I hope they take in the whole thing, including the title. He's obviously waiting, and has been for awhile--with the snow gathering. He's not waiting with someone, moving and talking, or the snow and the hair would be more disturbed.

The only thing that might have made it better (for this category) is perhaps having him look over the photographers shoulder, or off more to the side, instead of directly at the camera. With him looking at the camera, it engages us, and we're part of the scene. He doesn't seem as alone (and silent) that way.

I still say--excellent shot - 8

Before it all Starts
by raish

Comment:
I'm sorry, I couldn't rate this very high, because it was so dark, and I couldn't tell what was in the picture...

Before Talkies
by DCrest01

Comment:
I like the idea, but I'm afraid it didn't work for me--I remember these being so loud!! Now if the film had gotten all tangled up and wouldn't work anymore--no sound, period, I probably would have rated it very high.