Red 139
by Jak

Comment:
Color nicely manipulated out, except the red (did you mean to have the dumpster's label show up, too?) Focus is very good, sharp! (yes, the telephone wires look jagged, but that's not your fault or even the camera's!) 6 Swash

Incredible Shrinking Man
by Swashbuckler

Comment:
Just how strange would one want? Would anyone that voted this a 1, 2 or 3 be kind enough to explain what they thought was bad about this? I promise, no arguements, I just want to be a better photographer, please help me.

Custom Tint
by spiderman

Comment:
From the lines of the web and other edges, I think the focus seems good, but the color manipulation (at least I hope that's from post processing) distorts the image so that I'm not fully certain. (joke: what happened to the rest of the vehicle?) To me, this is overly processed...it looks more like a well done painting than a photo. (Was that your objective???) 6 Swash

Windows
by vjoz

Comment:
Very good focus and color (well taken shot). The window frames are bizarrely painted (just noting it, no score effect). For a second, I thought you might be going for an optical illusion with the angle of the shot and framing, but honestly, they look the same size. The reflections in the window glass and the colorful curtains work against each other to confuse the viewer (me). 6 Swash

New York Windows
by dimitrii

Comment:
Nice building shot, the two seagulls are a big plus. Contrast is good, but the sky didn't seem to take the black and white well, it appears between grainy and very grainy. It's a nice building with neat trimmings, but it doesn't "grab" me visually.
6 Swash

Abandoned
by RiderGal

Comment:
Mostly well taken photo, there's at least two doors, so challenge well met. The two foreground items are a bit distracting (the bar of wood coming from the bottom of the frame - and the part of the door leaning on the wall on the right side of the frame). Plus the shadows created by the flash aren't very appealing (don't add anything but maybe a bit of depth). Visually, I don't care for it, sorry, it just doesn't appeal to me. 6 Swash

Windows of Opportunity
by CreativeFlyPhoto

Comment:
Very well taken shot, narrow DOF works very well in this case. This is a wildly different "take" on the challenge topic (so creative in that respect), but visually, not that appealing. 6 Swash

Eternal Doorway
by Anachronite

Comment:
This is a wonderful piece! If not inverse coloration, it seems close to it. The doors seem grainy, but I think that's your post processing. The arches above the door are perfect! I think I could have lived with the bottom of the doors being the bottom of the photo and (impossible wish) the little bricks in the upper corners, but what are you to do? (Maybe a higher, more straight on shot???) 9 Swash

Cottage
by Gotcha

Comment:
Very cool shot!
Comment editted - My BAD. I did not enter this challenge and did not see the extra rules for it. Sorry. Awesome shot! Love the curly things. 10 Swash
(please for give a dumb old man!)

Window & Light
by Kathyc

Comment:
Nice sillhouettes, but not much else. The crop adds a little interest, but not enough. 5 Swash