Circular Slides
by chariot

Comment:
This is an interesting, different approach to this challenge. Credit for creative thinking. Shot well taken. Now for the bad stuff. This could easily be considered using someone else's materiel as your subject (against site rules), but on the plus side, you "give credit" to the Discovery Channel, so this might be acceptable. Next, as a "creative" approach, it's great, but my personal guidelines for this challenge cannot accept this as the challenge intent (IMO).

After much thought, I am going to give you a 5 and not recommend for DQ. Remember, this is just one idiot's thoughts. Don't let it get to you. Swash

Spectrum
by daverx7

Comment:
Nicely done. small nit about glass positioning, but doesn't really effect the overall shot. (I like symetry) Photo 9 Transparency 9 total 9 swash

Neon Marguerita
by lecalan

Comment:
Whao baby! This is nearly too busy. Good restraint. Funky ice cubes. I like the reflections around the upper edge of the glass. (fake flowers? slightly tacky) Photo 9 Transparency 8 total 8 swash

Sample in a Jar
by miller

Comment:
Is her name Sample? Very artistic. The woman's face appears as if it were drawn, not photographed. Don't like the shadows on the glass. This would have been really cool cropped just to her face, but then nobody would have gotten this. Photo 9 Transparency 9 total 9 swash

Whats the temperature?
by warglory

Comment:
Good question, I can't tell (see title, joke) Nice shot. I like how the edges of the thermometer cut off the temp bulbs, very interesting. Lots of interest, good focus and lots of great color. Photo 9 Transparency 9 total 9 swash

Rainy Day
by BambooChica

Comment:
Kinda grey, less than appealing shot. Good focus. Photo 5 Transparency 6 total 6 swash

Waxy Galaxy
by RedRuthann

Comment:
Cool concept, but way too busy. Very good color/focus. Photo 9 Transparency 8 total 8 swash

Bubble
by davidc

Comment:
Nice photo. My background was also busy, but flat. Don't know which is better, I see advantages in your version, but honestly prefer mine better (vain, yes indeed)
Photo 9 Transparency 8 total 9 swash

Camden Yards Atmosphere
by Amandrew

Comment:
What is the transparent object? At best, a VERY loose interpretation, as far as I can see. I am guessing, but is your "transparency" the light streams from the stadium lights? (too loose for me) For example: if this was through regular glass, prove it with water droplets or the like. If I am wrong, I apologize now.
Photo 9 Transparency -1 total 5 swash

Aaaaaah
by pauld

Comment:
Well taken, but less than appealing. Photo 5 Transparency 6 total 5 swash