At JFK Airport
by oksamit

Comment:
This would be much more powerfull as an 8x10 but has too much detail to try and make this small.
TC

Protest in Mexicali
by cimarron98

Comment:
There is too much reflection in the windows. It's a little distracting...
TC

Overhauling History
by mbardeen

Comment:
Very nice shot! I love the way candidness along with the repitions and simple color scheme!
TC

Recovered Marshes
by zeuszen

Comment:
Just an observation...It's been a long time since I looked through NG but I don't recall any shots that were at an angle such as this one. Nice shot overall...
TC

Right before my best buddy's head fell off for Makro III
by Harz_Joerg

Comment:
From the Critique Club

This is a very unique shot for the challenge. I love the use of the mirror that gives an effect similar to a wide angle lens. The focal point and DOF are dead on. Combining with the fish eye effect, this gives an almost dreamlike feel!

There are a couple of nit picky minor things compositionaly that I don't like. There is some kind of artifact on the lower left curve of the mirror that is a touch distracting. The image isn't cropped evenly on the left and right in relation to the circle of the mirror.

I know some people may not have liked the added elements (tissues and filter), but I think that they only add to the illusion of someone working hard to get the 'perfect macro' shot!

Nice job
TC

My past is fading, my present is clear, but my future is obscured
by AmiYuy

Comment:
My original comment (though maybe a little harsh) still stands. I like the shot in general. I DID make an assumption that the photographer (You, Ami) had more controll over the shot! Anytime that anyone with our camera has a shot that they think is worth entering is IMHO an accomplishment! Good job Ami!

Step up-Step down
by justine

Comment:
That's GOT to be casino carpeting...
TC

Home
by johnm

Comment:
I really like this one for some reason. For all it's plainess, it DOES make me feel like home. Not my home, but somewhere that I could spend some comfort time!
TC

Synchronicity
by crabappl3

Comment:
Too much border...
TC

My Little Chickadee
by vtruan

Comment:
Looks underexposed and like the white balance is wrong...
TC