Sea Stacks
by angkokweng

Comment:
Not sure tat Black and white works best for this, would have been interested to see a colour version. The blues and browns then could have contrasted well against each other

Heart of Stone
by Senay

Comment:
I like the colour you have acheived with the sky in this shot. The midday sun though causes quite harsh shaddows and flat lighting, which does not help the overall image.......Also, the crop on the right seems a little awkward.

The creation isn't finished
by Glanni

Comment:
Thats true. I like how you hqave made a simple bend int eh river interesting. The blue of the water and the red of the bank are really good. I don'ty know how wide the river is at this point, as I do wish I could see the rest of the bend in the shot, rather than it being cropped off.

Millions of years
by fridjo

Comment:
Plenty of years there, however the overall image just seems to lack a subject or focal point, and the colours are not strong enough to carry the image like it is..........

Black rock point
by nico_blue

Comment:
A nice long exposure image, however the horrizon crossing at the centre of the image doesn't work for me.................

Layers
by FocusPoint

Comment:
A great location for the challenge. I do not know whether it is that the image horizon is not straight, or due to the heavy subject loading on one side, but it feels like the image needs to be rotated....Maybe an illusion, but it feels down at the right.
Also, some additional Post Processing I feel could have got more out of this image. Ie use of the Shaddows/Highlight function in PS (or similar) would have allowed more detail to be retained in the upper area of the rocks (white area) a richer red for the rest of the rocks, a richer green as well in the vegetation and therefore produce a really striking image.

Water and Rocks
by Pug-H

Comment:
A really interesting rock. I think you might have cropped this a little too tight, as the surrounding water and greenery would have beenr eally good to frame and balance the photo. Furthermore, having additional space to the right, with the flowing water, I feel would have added both extra interest, and ofset the rock well.

Dinosaur Walk
by delin

Comment:
An interesting spot to photograph, and one that works well for the challenge. Some different lighting to give a more dramatic feel could have really made this image one of the best. The current bright patch at the bottom right for me is a distraction from the overall photo

Evolution's Window.......from pebbles to pylons
by bcenu

Comment:
A different but well thought of image for the challenge, that has also been well executed. I probably would have cropped the upper inch, which just has the wood beam, and left the next wood beam and the pillars to naturally frame the image, thereby avoiding the large brown area at the top of the image.

Amethyst
by hajeka

Comment:
A great collection of stones, and well lit, as you have managed to avoid the bright overpowering reflections that most people get when photographing these angular pieces of rocks......