Reflected Sunset
by KristinaG

Comment:
There are a few things I want to say about this. One - I love the sunrise(set). Awesome colors. Two - I like the reflection! Three - I am not sure I like the left set of trees. They seem like you might have done a bit of selective brightening and it sort of came out flat in color. And lastly number four - I think you could have gotten away without the bottom layer of grass. Either that or added more of it. Either way would have worked. :)

Autumn Pond
by cloudsme

Comment:
I like it but then again I wish I would have seen more water. To me the water isn't a major subject in this. I wish you were closer to the water or would have shown more of it. The colors are great and you picked a good day with a dramatic sky. Well done.

Natural Mountain Pond
by Len Scap

Comment:
I like the top half of this shot. The bottom on the other hand Seems a bit soft. A little bit of sharpening would have made this shot a ton better than it already is. That mountain is awesome for sure though!

Along the Delaware
by banmorn

Comment:
Seems like there is a bit of a halo around the tall buildings. Other than that though I like the stars created by the lights. And I like the fact that the water is a major subject. Well done.

Autumn Flow
by Dennisheckman

Comment:
I love this one. My only issue with this is the frame. The blue to me does not work well with this. I think just a solid black frame would have done the job nicely. I love the colors in the trees! And the water is really inviting for a bit of a swim. :)

In the Quiet, in the Stillness
by markwiley

Comment:
I really like this shot but I almost feel like the sky is too bright and doesn't have enough color. There are some blown out highlights in there. Other than that though I love the fallen tree(s) and the reflections they give.

Casey Stoner's Island - Moto GP time - Australia
by bcenu

Comment:
Unfortunately this doesn't really meet the challenge. I think of this challenge as having the water be the main subject. If this were a street photography challenge this would score high.

dawn on the James
by jcar

Comment:
I like the photo... I do... BUT I can't imagine other people will. Here is why. I think the crop is too harsh. This in turn made you put in a frame that is too big. This is just my opinion of course.

A river runs past it
by amsterdamman

Comment:
HDR is called for this. The left side is too dark for the right side. The windmill is standoff(ish) enough to be the subject even if the photo is vibrant and colorful.

Water Under The Bridge
by Basta

Comment:
Oh! I like this one! This is going to sound a bit odd at first but I have learned that people like things like bridges and thing to come from the left and go into the from that way. A simple "flip" would have made the effect possible.

P.s. - I like the frame. :)