Growing Life
by peter

Comment:
Cute idea. Too bad its a little OOF. I would've like to have seen this cropped a little closer to the subjects. and without the bandaid on the finger.

Which Came First -- The Turtle or The Egg?
by Lydia

Comment:
That may be one of the cutest turtle pics I've ever seen. :) The detail and lighting on him is excellent. Part of me almost thinks he looks too good to be a real turtle. lol I would've liked to have seen the rest of the egg in the shot, though, and the lighting on the egg shells is off to me. The right side is very bright and the left side is kind of an off/splotchy color. It looks like pieces from two different eggs.

Playing with Clay
by phlover

Comment:
An original approach, but it doesn't really do it for me.. Some areas are OOF and the reflection actually feels a little distracting. I do like the brightness of the colors though. It looks a little like the clay on the right is a giant, colorful clam that made all these colorful pearls around it. :)

What came before, she watches after
by nzbayleys

Comment:
This is a very beautiful photo. However, it doesn't say "Before and After" to me. Unless you think about it as she has been here before we came and will remain here after? No, it doesn't quite work for me.. Sorry. I would've rated this higher if it were a different challenge topic.

No chickens were hurt
by justamistere

Comment:
I like the original take this has, but I almost feel like there's too much in this picture; It detracts away from the B&A subject (eggs). I would've liked this better if it were cropped/zoomed in closer to the eggs. I like the hatchet though; Its unexpected. You must have some kind of contempt for eggs. :)

Burst
by artvet

Comment:
While I think this shot is neat (and probably took a lot of skill and shots to capture at just the right moment), it seems a little flat to me somehow. Maybe its the lighting?

Bubbles & Curves
by choltmeier

Comment:
Is that a real person or a doll, out of curiosity? Mostly its the bubbles that make me think that; It looks like a close-up of a lot of small bubbles, rather than how a real bubble bath usually looks.

This would have been an excellent entry to a "Curves" challenge.

Kiddie Krack
by ocasta

Comment:
This looks more orange than red to me... Maybe its my monitor??

the old rose
by aplomb76

Comment:
I thought this photo was spectacular; Its my favorite from the challenge. I was sure this was going to be on the front page, but this challenge had quite a lot of interesting photos to compete with... You'll get it next time! :)

Hot Potato
by ottersden

Comment:
When I saw this, I thought "Dragon Egg". My mind did not come to potato until I read the title. :P Very nice.