Going Down
by Toniann220

Comment:
I wonder if the intention here wouldn't have been better supported by a tigher crop and a portrait format? 5

Caliente
by KevinRiggs

Comment:
This is one image I would far rather see unsilhouetted! Still, you've forced me to use my imagination. (Which I'm doing now.................) 8

Fisherman at Dawn — Red River Beach
by Bear_Music

Comment:
My only question is: 1/ how would this have worked if the fisherman had been used to connect the sea with the sky? I'm not fond of this border. Otherwise, a lovely image. 8

Americas Temples
by chaddybones

Comment:
If you'd have placed the sun directly behind the buildings, would their outline have been sharper? That certainly would have avoided the unhelpful white blob. The black silhouette on the left doesn't help that much, either. But, beyond these quibbles, this is a potentially very good image. I like the attempt at combining motifs rather than just shoot a straightforward subject. 7

Engaged
by caba

Comment:
This image is so nearly perfect. The warmth and romanticism are shown so well in the background. My feeling is that the faces needed to be a little more distinct (by being closer to the centre of the frame?) and the glasses far more so. 7

Bad old Puddytat waiting for the birds
by Xilebo

Comment:
I like this nice image, especially the colour and detail in the flowers, but I don't care for the border. 5

Silhouetted by Power
by lilnukee

Comment:
It seems to be that you've inverted the challenge theme - the main subject is far brighter than all but the lighted section. 3

painting works
by rhipster

Comment:
This is a nice idea well executed. However, it's not my cup of tea. 6

Photographers at dawn
by allankent

Comment:
Oh - nice. I can just see this gracing a book cover perfectly. I really like the tonal range here, as well as the composition and combined ideas. Lovely stuff. 10

Father and Son
by twm122

Comment:
This lovely idea suffers from too much extraneous background spoilers. Also, there seems to be too much bottom. 4