Blueberry and Apple Muffins
by train

Comment:
Good Points:well composed, and a nice subject. Inclusion of flower is good idea. Good textures on the tablecloth.
Bad Points:slightly underlit with the white plate not being white enough. try using curves if you have photoshop. Also a bit more blue at the bottom, perhaps a bit too closley cropped.
Overall Score:7

Rice-Stuffed Cornish Hens
by Sonifo

Comment:
Good Points: At first I was thinking 3, too cluttered, but it kind of works I think, I would expect to see this kind of thing in an old cook book, a traditional one. Composed well, and great colors. Very seasonal
Bad Points:Perhaps slightly too much going on..and would have left out the china.
Final Score:8

H2O
by kiwiness

Comment:
The best idea for the challenge, full marks to you for that.

I think the lighting could be better, but to be fair I don't know how, it just doesn't seem to stand out. perhaps becasue the shadows are so hard? I really don't know. Or even the dark area in the top right, but if removed you would lose some depth...mmm perhaps just right as it is! Great shot!

Anyway, it's a sure fire 10 from me, best of luck

Sun rays
by pitsaman

Comment:
yet another beauty. u stand in road?

a cone exposed in a single shot
by ursula

Comment:
Good points: nice colours and great composition
Bad Points: none - but the border is a bit too thick for my taste.
Score:8

Exposed To the Cold World
by sagestudio

Comment:
Good Points: good symetrics (sp)
Bad Points: doesn't meet challenge - unless she is normally covered in something?NOT a snapshot mind you ;)

Video Head
by MWitt

Comment:
Good Points:closeness and composition are pretty good
Bad Points: not the most original idea and would have been better if dusted beforehand.
Score:4

No Makeup
by TooCool

Comment:
Good Points:see your idea and like it.
Bad Points:overall it makes for a dull photograph. no interesting focal points of detail or color.
Score:3

Milkweed Pod
by BigMo

Comment:
Good Points:very good subject matter and composition
Bad Points:looks ever so slightly dull, a touch-up with levels to give some highlights - all seems a bit flat. also your image is too small.
Score:

Sweetness Revealed
by slgardner

Comment:
Good Points:quite like the composition and colors
Bad Points:reflections are distracting, and could be a touch sharper on the chocolate. border really ruins this.
Score:5