The Shining Crescent
by tyt2000

Comment:
Seems slightly tilted. I would have gotten rid of the light on the sides all together. The composition here is fantastic. You have a great eye. I don't care for the sepia in this image, it does nothing for me. 8

Does anyone care that it's raining out here?
by admart01

Comment:
What a face. I love to see people submit GOOD pet shots. I hate how people bitch (no pun intended) and moan about it all the time. Dogs can do no wrong by me, only photographers that think any photo of their dog is good. You get a 10 from me because this really is good and quality photography like this should never be frowned upon no matter how cliche the subject.

Ray Of Light
by qmdi

Comment:
Beautiful. Perfect. Nothing to say really. Might get scored low since the view is not out the window or reflected in the window, hence it is not a window view, but I still give it a 10.

window to the past
by nordic

Comment:
The washed out sky and the straightline at the top really take away from this fantastic image. If this is somewhere near where you live you absolutely must go out here when the lighting is perfect. Perhaps a slightly wider crop would add more balance. 9

A Glimps Back in Time
by LtHousLady

Comment:
The more I look at this image the more i like it. The off-kilterness adds to the feeling of vertigo looking down as if falling into the past. The lines of the window, wal, ledge, shadows, and horizon make interesting shapes. I can tell a lot of thought was put into the composition. 9

Waiting
by mariomel

Comment:
I like the contrast of highkey and lowkey here and the silhouette with the hat is very effective. I need to go out and buy a cool hat for the silhouette challenge I think! 10

the Prowler
by spydr

Comment:
Great idea. I like the blue light from the television set and the fact that the tv is actually seen reflected in the mirror. Get rid of that bright spot on the door and give it a gentle run through neatimage. 9

I want to ride too...
by cbeller

Comment:
This is one of the best shots in the challenge, one of the few in which the off center placement of the blurry windowframe actually works as it is balanced by the kids silhouette. The vintage sepia look works well with the candid nature of the shot and the timelss horse. 10

a Room with a view
by Nazgul

Comment:
Love your toning. I'd love it if you could share your editing workflow to achieve the tone after the challenge is over. 10

Sunset Storm
by Imagineer

Comment:
This is my favorite photo in the challenge. Excellent work. 10