Al for Aluminum
by AmeedEl-Ghoul

Comment:
Hello from Critique Club :)

I see steel more than aluminum, but I don't care what the subject is, let's take a look at the photo.

Nice colors, sharp and nice focus on the edge of the "thing" You should have dodge the bright area a little bit more, but it's not that bad. I like the lighting here, from back, the shadows are the main attraction (I know you were hoping people would like them too).

Having three dimension look on your photo is giving much better feeling rather than a flat photo.

I believe 5.8 for this photo is pretty much on target... over average. The composition got you a good points, sharpness and color also got you some more good votes.

If you had only the front end of this thing and not the back of it, I think it would look better. Don't cut it, whatever this is, but put cardboard or paper behind it, and shoot it that way. You won't have many shadows in the back, but I like cleaner photos :)

I checked your page, photos look very nice. You do have a style, develop that and you might be one of kind.

Keep up the good work, and practice without mercy :)

Leo

Helium "He"
by mbrutus2009

Comment:
Hello from Critique Club :)

Nice sharp image with little over exposed white areas at the end of the balloon. It probably exposed little wrong and probably some work done to fix it. I might be way off, but this photo looks like 1-good imagination 2-bad execution of the imagination.

Too much dark area on your photo, you should not have the tied end of the balloon right on the middle of the frame. Talking about the frame, if you did have a thin red frame with this photo, it would look much better. Try to see it bit more cropped, and next time try to give a bit softer light, I think there is a flash or something used that's shining too much on tip of the balloon.

Keep on clicking, you will get there, I have no doubt :)

Leo

Forged In Flame
by SnapperL

Comment:
Hello from Critique Club :)

Oh man, you do have great imagination. I don't care about the challenge subject, but I will get down to this picture without thinking if matches to the challenge or not.

Technically, perfect. I like the sharpness. Very well exposed. I love the composition, with ring, the black area on the right and angle... I also like the framing.

I think this is one of the good works I saw in DPC with one color. This should have been around 6.2

I checked out your photos, and you do have talent. You have big imagination and ability to capture them. Keep up the good work.

Leo

Surprisium
by posthumous

Comment:
Hello from Critique Club :)

I am not sure what to say about this picture. I checked your website and you do have good stuff, natural and good stuff but I must say this doesn't look like one of your work.

but anyway, let's get down the business.

I have no idea Surprisium, I think it means something about surprise?

I like 1 quarter of this photo which is standing out pretty good. I don't like the way sky, clouds and wires on the window but only the face. I am not even sure if that's your place, or someone else's, if you did have chance, I would suggest you to wait a bit more, have sun go down a bit more, darker outside and lighter inside... even a little spotlight on the face could be pretty interesting.

This photo looks like entered just to see what people would say rather than competing in the challenge.

Keep up the good work (not this, this is horrible) and show us better work of yours :)

and thanks for the great work you have done for DCP community :) we all appreciated.

Leo

Edited to fix a Word character in here :P

Message edited by author 2008-11-22 03:17:14.

I N S P I { R E D }
by Breeee123

Comment:
Here I say it, this is too much even for DPC... too good... excellent, and needs to go higher contests to win better prices... I mean it.

Congratulations from bottom of my heart. As soon as I saw this I had no doubt in my mind it would be winner, and be winner big...

Leo

Somebody forgot to cancel the lawn mooing service
by Nuzzer

Comment:
Hello from Critique Club :)

In this photo, I love the old house and where it stands. It sure is an abandoned building. I am not too sure about the cow though.

Technically, perfect. Very sharp. Colors are perfect.

Compositing, is not bad at all, I would get rid of the cow and get a little closer to the house. After all, what you are trying to say is the house itself. The paint and the old structure is already giving us the story, surroundings and the cow a bit more stuff than I would like to see here.

I would give 6 to this photo, because there is no 5.5 in voting. Don't be mad at me but in my opinion, this is around 5.8, 5.7 photo rather than 6+. I would say 6 if I can see more cropped version even with the cow...

I checked your work, and you seem like know what you're doing, so keep up the good work. Here is one advice, don't enter an image if you have even little doubt in your mind. I said that because you are a very good photographer, you can do much better work. Trust your instincts :)

Good luck,

Leo

Solidarity
by Rino63

Comment:
Hello from Critique Club :)

I think the story here if you abandoned a dog, there will be another one who will be comforting it.... which is a nice story, I can see it from the first look.

Technically, nice exposure, only white dog's tail is over exposed, but it's normal. I wish you would wait for the sun go down a bit more, or hurry up before sun goes up that high, I don't know the time, so basically the sunlight here bit harsh.

Composition is pretty good. The other dog far side is taking a bit more attention, although I couldn't see it at first, I know it's there. The road itself is very nice; DOF is very nice, not too harsh, meaning not too tight.

I personally would crop this a bit more to bring out the "feeling" of the story. I would bring them to middle; keep it bit more tight...

I checked your work... Good stuff you have there. I think you are pretty close to get your first ribbon ;) Just keep trying. I always tell everyone to check out the previous winners, they are very encouraging bunch of samples.

Good luck

Leo

Abandoned To The Elements
by Ter

Comment:
Hello from Critique Club :)

This is a nice, ordinary some sort of an "animal barn" photo. From where I stand, I can't see any abondancy but I see a structure in middle of a field.

Technically, exposure is right on the money for outside lights. You did not want to show inside the structure anyway, you thought just to show empty black interior and the long uncut field should do the job... but, it seems like didn't work well.

Composition, I do like the way it is, although I personally crop it bit more and have that barn a bit closer without eliminating the plants and sky.

I visited your page and checked out your work. I see you do have the eye, nice compositions, clean images.. you are on a right road :) If you want to be more successful in DPC, advice 1-Check out previous winners 2-keep your images simple 3-sharp and good contrast images most likely the winners.

and the rest, practice practice and more practice. Don't be discourage if you don't win anything for a long time and keep trying :)

Good luck

Leo

abandoned house...
by mbrutus2009

Comment:
Hello from Critique Club :)

Let's take a look at your photo and try to understand why did you get such a low points and last place.

Technically, it is a nice exposed photo with some over exposed front yard.

Composition is nice. I like the way you had house up front and still kept the palm tree in the back and the yard up front to show the abandoncy(!).

Post process, is nicely done. This could be a nice photo for "digital art" challenge. You saw a house, with lots of plants front that tells us it was abandoned. Probably there were some other cracks or broken windows but post process is hiding all that and giving us a clearer image.

I don't know the surrounding of this house, but if you did go back a little more and took a bit more of the house with more plants, and instead of digital work, change the colors a bit faded, and let us see more damage on the house you would not be at last :)

It's a nice photo, it came last because didn't match to challenge subject in my opinion.

I checked your other photos. You do need some practice on finding more interesting and colorful subjects. Everyday and everyone's shot won't do in DPC, you have to be unique. Make sure your focus is correct, contrast and colors are alive... and try to tell stories with your photos, if not be artistic, but not with post process, with your compositions :)

Good luck,

Leo

Winter sun
by gisli

Comment:
Hello from Critique Club :)

This photo definitely doesn't deserve 2... but hey, there are all kinds of "people" in dpc unfortunately.

Well deserved 6.6 I think right on the money. I would give 9 personally or 8 but not 10.

Technically very nice photo, with perfect exposure. I like the way you put the sun on the middle and kept more earth and less sky. Nothing against the sky. I think my only complain would be the reflection on the water being a bit harsh, and maybe on the ice itself right under the sun. But that's about it. The rest is perfect.

Very sharp photo, colors are very good, post process is done right on the money. I would do something about the bright areas in post process though.

I checked your other photos. You are from Iceland, no more to say :) we know that area is a ribbon machine :D

I feel like I shouldn't even critique your photo, since you are superior to my level, although sometimes it is nice to know what other ordinary earthlings think about masters work LOL

Very nice... keep up the good work :)

Leo