Orange (CW)
by tehben

Comment:
Here's my comments, specifically because you've marked it CW

If I were voting in this challenge I would have given it a 7. I really like the composition and the uncluttered feeling. The balance of it feels just right with his hand close the right edge balanced by the ball at the bottom left. Very nice.

The Friendly Spooners (CW)
by dtremain

Comment:
Here's my comments specifically because you've marked it CW.

If I was voting in this challenge I would have given you a 5. I like your subject and you've managed to capture it mostly isolated from a potentially distracting background, but not quite. I feel the car behind and especially the orange in the background is a little too distracting.

Toledo, Peoria & Western (CW)
by kleski

Comment:
Here's my comments specifically because you've marked it CW

If I was voting in this challenge I would have given it a 5. While I feel it's an OK photo, the composition doesn't grab me. I'm torn between thinking it's too tight a crop (I want to see all of the train), or not tight enough (more of an abstract). I also wonder if you could have made it look more imposing by taking the picture from a lower angle.

Pate's home for retired warriors (cw)
by Yo_Spiff

Comment:
Here's my comments (because you put the CW in the title)

If I was voting on this challenge, I would have given you a 6. I like your composition especially how you've framed the flying boat with the foreground aircraft. My one minor issue is that I feel you could have cropped off the right hand edge slightly to loose the wing-root so that distraction was removed.

Public Spaces are for Robots, Too
by citymars

Comment:
He looks to be the master of his environment

Wind Me, Baby
by citymars

Comment:
I'm not going near him to wind him up, unless I get some assurance he understands the phrase "don't bite the hand that feeds you"!

Camouflage
by citymars

Comment:
What a perfect disguise!

Fernando
by Pug-H

Comment:
It's a good job there's a lot of Abba songs. I've a feeling this is going to take a while.

Ride the wake
by Connor

Comment:
It's a great capture, but I find that border is intrusive to the point of overwhelming your subject

Everlasting Laughter
by gsal

Comment:
It's a marvellous capture, but I really don't see what the fat border is adding to the overall image