On the Night Shift
by Gunnsi

Comment:
Compositionally this is a real tough call. You wanted the lights and the reflections obviously, but you have no real foreground except that tiny triangle in the right corner. Foregrounds need to be stronger and more prominent. There is a huge expanse of black in the bottom left which contributes nothing, and the sky is taking up half the image without contributing too much either.

My recomendation would be to have concentrated on a smaller section of the town lights and make a stronger feature of the narrow stripe which actually cotains the reflection. Get in closer next time

Candle Eye
by Abstract

Comment:
The candle cannot be distinguished, it might have well been a fluorescent light.
The greatest problem though is the composition - you have cropped off the right hand side of the eye, leaving a huge expanse of out of focus nose on the left hand side. Why? I guess you were thinking of the rule of thirds, well in this case you could have broken that rule.

Majestic Stand
by AllanL

Comment:
OMG a headless duck!!!
The reflection is not strong enough to carry this composition. The reflected duck is too dark because you exposed for the real duck, but then you cropped it out. If you are intending the reflection to be the major element then expose for that and lose the original totally.

Urban Reflections
by Hoochie

Comment:
The contrast in this image is way too low. It feels like we are looking through frosted glass. It also needs something inthe foreground as nothing really happens in the image until halfway up. The bottom third could be cropped as it doesn't contribute anything to the image

Reflections Golden on a Pond
by whitewolf

Comment:
Ooooh hold back that saturation slider a little

Lake house reflections
by photomankc

Comment:
Hold back on the saturation slider just a little

Icy Gaze
by LalliSig

Comment:
Wooohooot !

Knew it was yours - just knew.
Cracking shot, exceptionally beautiful model.

The Swirling Leaves
by jtlee321

Comment:
Nice one. I was going to do something similar, but in the UK the leaves haven't fallen yet. This is simply stunning.

Alone and Barren at Dusk
by gg3rd

Comment:
Hold back that saturation slider ;-)

Serenity
by LalliSig

Comment:
Thats one helluva portrait, 7.2 but no cigar, thats tough