Watery Reflections
by Steveinnz

Comment:
A photo should be memorable. I can see this scene by just looking trough my window.
That is only 1 out of 100 problems this photo is dealing with. I'm not going to point them
all out. Be more creative than this. And yes, use aparture to put things out of focus.
(blurry). Or it ends up looking flat and we can't see the edges of relevant parts.

Monsanto Lake, Autumn
by 3eyedcrow

Comment:
Very nice colors and location. I personaly don't like this kind of composition where the
frame is splin in 2 very similar parts. Ofcorse this is the challenge to blame :-)
But I would cut alot of reflection OR real trees. Don't have to show it all.
That way you'd be able to get more creative composition and/or apply the rule of thirds,
one thing this photo misses so much.
But I don't mean to puch this critique too far. I love the picture! Congrats

The Sun Is Mine
by Neuferland

Comment:
Ideas don't matter if you brake every rule there is to photography
and didn't get a good resault. Composition and exposure are horrible.

Fuego
by qbicle

Comment:
There is not much reflected to be worth of shooting (in my opinion).

Seagulls on thin ice
by Gauti

Comment:
Lovely. Very interesting and creative. Congrats

The Men's Room
by elemess

Comment:
I very much like the idea and the subject reflected here, but the composition of this
shot is really bad. This way you got alot of undesired background. Only left 1/2 is
interesting (to me).

Deep "Down"town
by rjkstesch

Comment:
Whatever it is, it's great! Reflection without mirrors is a description, that confused
me alot for this challenge. I don't know if that's a mirror in your photo but it looks beautifull.

Rowe Woods
by sibeling

Comment:
I don't like shooting landscapes couse they all look great:-)
Therefore, borring to me.

Boathouse
by rr_meyer

Comment:
P&S

Double Vision
by Pooba

Comment:
mmmm, nice. Too much black on the left + sky almost blown out. I'd cut the left 1/3 out
and expose for sky.