Firey Red Sunset
by sherpet

Comment:
adding my congratulations on a beautiful capture, great colors!

Jacque

"Wake Up Little Susie"
by wackary

Comment:
a little too small, should be close to 640 on at least one side

Creation
by JH

Comment:
I skipped voting on this one, sorry, though it is technically very nicely done, I did NOT like it. So, as I refuse to give a good image that meets the challenge a low score, I just skip them, wish others would do the same, btw!! Anyway, FIRST thing I thought of when this photo came up during voting was "E T ripoff", understand that it very well may not be, but that is all I saw in it. I am sorry that I do not like it, but..... people are different. AND, I do say, it is WELL done!

Jacque

Exclusive Spy Photo! Cheddar Cow Captured!
by C_Steve_G

Comment:
Apologies, in advance!!

First, so as not to cow tow to you, this could have been an udder disaster, but you horned in and milked it for all it was worth! Now hope you do not get de-fence-ive, but you must weed through all the comments and squeeze out the good ones!

Actually, I really think you did a good job on this, missed a couple small white spots on cow, but that may be natural??? LOL. May trying to crop the photo different, getting the cow on maybe the lower left third line? Think that may give it a bit more pizazz, this is of course, MY OPINION< only.. LOL

Jacque

LiveStrong
by Melethia

Comment:
Think most has been said, only thing I could think of to try is along the lines of what eschelar said, but I would TRY to make the rose to "O" in S T R (Rose) N G, not sure if it could be done, but maybe if done well, would have increased your score a lot. My opinion, we understand! LOL

Jacque

Blossoms and Yellow Bridge
by Pug-H

Comment:
I really like this one, not sure how it would have fared in the "Yellow" challenge, but to me it is very well done and beautiful!

Jacque

Ready for bathtime
by Cooz

Comment:
I did not vote on this one either, but would most likely have given it another 6, very nicely done, there is a VERY SLIGHT halo effect I see on this monitior around her "skirt" and the hair ribbon is a very slight distraction to me, because it is SO white also. Not a great fan of selective desat, but this is really one of the best I have seen! Think you did well with it, and not much to improve on, IMO!!

Jacque

rainy daisy
by rachelellen

Comment:
Only nine votes below 4, overall, people liked this photo, but only 11 votes over 7, says not many LOVED it. When I look at it, does not convey a bright, happy yellow, more a thoughtful, reflective hue. Not a bad thing at all, but may be why the main population (including me) said, good shot, but...........! Hope I am getting my elusive point across here, I think a LITTLE bit brighter may have made a world of difference, but, as always, that is MY OPINION!

Jacque

Freshly Painted
by Pug-H

Comment:
Well, my worthy opponent beat me here, first thing I thought was "Wish the dominant yellow line was on the thirds", honestly! Also may TRY, not sure if it would help or not, is the crop out from the right side enough so that white guard rail is gone. May help a LITTLE.

Jacque

PS I was one of the 62

Complementary Flower
by jorr

Comment:
Okay, if I have to comment on this one, all I will say is,

I LOVE IT I LOVE IT I LOVE IT

Nearly perfect shot!! Cannot get much better for me!!

Wow, someone may think I am trying to sleep with the photographer, so will stop now!!

Jacque

Message edited by author 2006-04-10 23:24:24.