Pure Sugar
by escapetooz

Comment:
Hey there from the Critique Club

Camera Work/Technical: Terrific model and wonderful color with this capture. Everything looks very crisp, save the cotton candy on the stick.

Lighting: I think the lighting accounts for the soft look the the candy has. I think that side of the frame is just a bit hot causing the candy to blend into the background. The large bright spot also creates a distraction that pulls the eye from the attractive model and the great expression.

Composition/Content: Very well planned and executed. I do agree that the glasses frame should either be up a little or down a little. Running it straight through the eyes makes the eyes look very distorted.

My Opinion: I like it, and I think that it should have scored much better even as it. Moving the glasses and toning down the left lighting would have surely boosted it as well.

Eric

Sticky - Ouch! Crown of Thorns
by pixeldust

Comment:
Hey there from the Critique Club

Camera Work/Technical: Very nice white balance choice, yielding great colors and strong tones. The bottom flower looks a little out of focus to me.

Lighting: The bottom flower is also just a bit overexposed. There are also some distraction hot spots on most of the thorns. Shooting at a different time of day might have helped this a bit.

Composition/Content: I like the flow you created with the angle of the vine. It serves well to pull the viewer's eye up and into the image. I think that the content is a bit lacking. While I fully understand your interpretation, it was apparently not what the voters were looking for.

My Opinion: I think that the voters had more of a messy liquid theme in mind. Even still, with a little sharper focus and a little less exposure, I think this capture would have finished much higher.

Eric

It's honey , honey
by clangley50

Comment:
Hey there from the Critique Club

Camera Work/Technical: Very clean, crisp focus, as well as a great depth of field. Also, your choice of white balance created very nice, warm tones providing a very inviting feeling to the image.

Lighting: I'd really like to see more light on the side of her face that is toward the camera. While the shadows fit nicely into this image, this part of her face is a bit too dark, thus pulling and holding the viewer's eye into the dark void.

Composition/Content: I agree that this one needed a tongue, but I also think some nose should have been included. Without the nose, the faces looks like it has some sort of uncomfortable deformity. This one was not far off the first place finisher. I even like your tones better, but you needed that nose.

My Opinion: I think the concept is far batter than the score it pulled, but it suffered in its execution. This really wasn't far from being a personal best. In my opinion, it only needed a nose and a little less shadow.

Eric

Sticky Notes (A scene from "Bruce Almighty")
by Shmee

Comment:
Hey there from the Critique Club

First of all, congrats on your best finish to date, as well as your third highest score. Well-done and well-deserved.

Camera Work/Technical: This looks like it was a ton of work. You came up with a nicely creative concept and executed it nicely as well. Your focus is crisp and clear, and your tones are near flawless. My only complaint is that the Gaussian blur you added gave it too much of a cartoon-type feel.

Lighting: Your use of HDR yielded very nice and even lighting results.

Composition/Content: Very creative. I really like the stickies that have fallen off onto the floor. This added a lot of interest to the photograph, thus giving the appearance of a man falling apart under stress. Well seen in your mind's eye.

My Opinion: Definitely the best of the three similar entries. I think that you may have pulled a bit higher of a score without the background blur, but it worked well with the voters as it is.

Eric

Melting Marshmallows
by dtouch1

Comment:
Hey there from the Critique Club

The first thing that strikes me about your image is the size. Smaller images always get hammered by the voters. There are some tutorials available to help with properly sizing images for the challenges. If you use PaintSHop, check HERE, and if you use PhotoSHop, check HERE.

Get this sizing issue handled, and I believe that your scores will fare much, much better. As far as the quality of the image goes, I'll echo the opinions of other voters that offered comments. There really is no focal point of the image, thus nothing really grabs the eye to offer any appeal. I can tell that it is sticky, but, without the title, I really couldn't see what it was. Work on your focus, as well as getting those images as large as possible.

Eric

Sticky Face
by karenk

Comment:
Hey there from the Critique Club

Camera Work/Technical: You captured terrific colors in this image. I also like your choice of settings, capturing all elements of interest in crisp focus.

Lighting: Your lighting is nice and even. You did a very nice job capturing this one without loosing any details in the shadows or blown highlights.

Composition/Content: I'd like to see your cropping loosened up a bit. Chopping off fingers or body parts near joints gives more of an accidental snapshot than an intentionally composed image.

My Opinion: You met the challenge well, but with a bit different composition, this score would have finished much higher.

Eric

Candy Cane
by sfmorris

Comment:
Hey there from the Critique Club

Camera Work/Technical: Nice capture and very nice focus. I also see some sort of color hue as well. I think that your post-processing is the culprit here.

Lighting: Excellent use of natural lighting. His face is lit terrifically and nothing is lost in shadows or blown highlights.

Composition/Content: I echo the adoration of previous commenters in that the expression is priceless. I do think that your cropping is just a bit tight. It give the image a very crowded and cramped feeling to it.

My Opinion: I like it, and I think it fits the challenge nicely. With a bit looser crop and less the hue, you score would have surely grown.

Eric

Sticky Magnets
by krgl

Comment:
Hey there from the Critique Club

Camera Work/Technical: Nice focus and fine settings to keep all the necessary elements in focus. Your chosen white balance also yields very nice tones and coloring.

Lighting: I really enjoy the warmth that you created with your lighting in this capture. The green and brown hues of the background work nicely to set your subject off.

Composition/Content: Very creative thinking to meet the challenge. It still seems a bit too centered to me, and the tilt of the tabletop(?), very horizon-like, gives the image an uncomfortable feel.

My Opinion: You absolutely met the challenge, but I don't think it was what the voters had in mind. Even still, with a bit different composition and a straightened horizon line, I think your score would have grown.

Eric

Sticky
by mediamst

Comment:
Hey there from the Critique Club

Camera Work/Technical: I think your soft focus hurt your score with this image. Studying the capture, it looks like a glamour-type soft filter of some sort was used. While it gives the image a appealing look, I think that it serves as more of a distraction than anything else. Looking through your previous comments, it seems that the voters felt the same way.

Lighting: Overall, the lighting is fairly even and nice, but the highlight at the top of the glass is a bit distracting. It competes too much with the viewer's eye, thus pulling the eye away from the meat of the composition.

Composition/Content: I really like the idea, and the sticky relation is easily made. However, I would like to have seen this one with a longer trail of chocolate. With short stream abruptly dropping out of the frame, you also cause the viewer's eye to drop right out with it. With a looser crop, you would have allowed the eye to flow more through the image rather than right out of the frame.

My Opinion: I believe that you did a nice job meeting the image is a very creative manner. I think with a more crisp focus and a litter better lighting, this one would have pulled a much better score. Even with the adjustments that could have been made, I think the 4.7 is a little low.

Eric

My World Photographs My Sky
by posthumous

Comment:
Hey there from ME!

Looking back through this challenge, I was surprised to see that this shot was tossed so far down the list. I thought that this one was executed very nicely, while maintaining the the integrity of photography.

Camera Work/Technical: Nice job keeping all the elements of the image in focus. I really like the crisp tree silhouettes, as well as your chosen WB and post-processing that really pulled a nice sky color.

Lighting: Great use of available light, and/or post-processing, to build a unique silhouetted image. I also like the highlight on the camera lens, as it works well pulling the eye through the various elements of the image.

Composition/Content: I think your composition is the strong point of this image. I really like the centered composition paired with the abruptly angled framing that you developed. This also works very nicely to pull the viewer's eye through and around the image.

My Opinion: This was a well thought out, and even better executed image that fits this challenge perfectly. While 5.7 is a strong score, I really expected this one to finish near the top of the heap. The voters missed this one, but who am I to think i understand the voters? Very nice work, and, in my opinion, one of your personal bests.

Eric