U n t i t l e d #12
by lumbardh

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club
By Inspzil

Composition - Nice simple composition. This is the strong, and weak point of this photo in my opinion. But I think that depends entirely on opinions. The simplicity of the composition in my opinion is what makes this image as good as it is. There isn't a lot of stuff to distract anyone from anything but the egg. On the flip side, this image is a little sterile for my tastes. I'm not saying its necessarily suffering from a lack of creativity, but that there is so much white and nothing else. I don't really like the degree that this photo is high key.

Technical - I think this image is effective overexposed, just not this much. Aside from that this is an extremely well taken photo.

Overall - Good image, just a bit bright for my tastes. It makes me think of hospitals for some reason.

Good luck in your future photos - Inspzil

Planet Egg
by GinaRothfels

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club
By Inspzil

Composition - This particular picture is real real close to being very good. The composition is pretty good. There is a little naturally occurring noise that I think takes away from the image considerably. I think the ring of bubbles and stuff over the top of the yolk and around that arc are very distracting. I think if you could remove those, you improve the composition substantially. There is also a small bunch of them on the bottom right of the yolk that would be better if removed. The ones in the white of the egg are a bit distorted and don't look so much like grains of sand. I think they can stay and not be too distracting. The angle and the macro effect really make this picture.

Technical - I think this picture, well focused would've done much better. The image is just a little bit short of sharp. It may be just one more "sharpen" away from that actually. The exposure could've been just a little more too to really bring out the yellow of the yolk. Its close. That may be possible to fix with PS as well.

Overall - A good concept for a picture. I think with a little honing this will be a really nice image. I think your pic was graded a little harshly probably due to the sharpness. I'd be lying if I didn't say that was a sticking point of mine too. Hope this could be a little helpful for you. Good luck in future challenges - Inspzil

The old toll bridge
by marbo

Comment:
Great tones. Nice skyline not to mention a very picturesque bridge. Great pic =9

Snow Bridge
by rafter

Comment:
I admire the way you used the limb to frame the picture in but I think it's not focused enough. Good little bridge portrayal in snow which is always tough to shoot it. You've exposed it just about right. Nice photo.

Swamp Trails
by PixelatedVisions

Comment:
Excellent photo. great reflections. The bridge could be a little more prominent in the photo, but I think it works the way it is. Great job - 9

Kymugla Covered Bridge
by Shiiizzzam

Comment:
Good use of black and white. Nice bridge. Very well framed and nicely taken

Covered Bridge
by Mustbelost

Comment:
The picture is pretty good except for all the colors except red are really sort of dull. A little nicer day might've worked out better for you. I really like the approaches to the bridge. That's a lot of attractive stonework

Whatever the future holds ....
by willem

Comment:
The haze makes this photo. Excellent photo! The people in the background are definitely a great addition to this already great photo. This has a little more of the metaphoric stuff than most or all of the other shots. Great capture. Good luck this week. this is a 10 from me

Extending Over the Severn Estuary
by Konador

Comment:
Difficult exposure conditions. Not badly done, but could stand to fixed somehow. If it was me I'd have concentrated my efforts on the bigger bridge in the background and got out from under this one to make the exposure game a fair one.

Katherine's bridge
by robster

Comment:
Unusual approach to this challenge. I can see how this can be taken by folks to be of poor taste. I don't think this fuzzy of a photo will ever do very well here. Naked chicks are cool, but I was really caught off guard by this photo which I'm sure was part of your intention. It looks like a photo taken in the '20s. Interpretive way to portray a bridge, however I don't feel its terrible effective either.